Where To Buy The Best Seafood Online

Important Note: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Content, pricing, offers and availability are subject to change at any time - more info.

Ah, the splendid bounty of American coasts, where the lobster bisque simmers richly, and Old Bay seasoning generously christens ample harvests. Our oceans, lakes, and rivers host a spectacular array of finned wonders and shell-encased delights, each with its own gastronomic lore and preparation rites. From the gentle kiss of smoke upon Alaskan salmon, unrivaled in its rich, velvety texture, to the lively blue crabs of Maryland, steamed to perfection and deftly seasoned with an array of spices, every coast tells a tale of culinary diversity and ingenuity. Yet, sourcing the cleanest, quality seafood is where it all starts, ensuring countless sublime creations thanks to the prime freshness. We’ve wrapped up the top places to buy the best seafood online in the US, reviewing fresh, frozen, and never-frozen shellfish markets that are sure to have customers hooked on their quality. 

Key Takeaways

Best Places To Buy Fresh Seafood Online

Each of the following top twenty fish markets class within the very best places to buy fresh seafood online in America. As we dive deep into the bounties they offer, you’ll uncover a spectrum from the traditional favorites to exotic underwater delicacies, each market with its unique flair and commitment to providing nothing short of ocean-fresh quality.

SOPO Seafood

Regions ServedLocal Delivery In Portland South Portland & Maine | Nationwide Overnight Shipping Available
DeliveryOnline Tracking Available For Non-Local Delivery Shipments
SmellMinimally Low Fishy Smell, Clean To Zero Odor Only
FlavorIndustry Leading Freshness & Delicious Flavor
Customer ServiceExcellent With Thoughtful, Proactive After Sales Service
AffordabilityModerate
ShippingMaine, Connecticut, Vermont, New Hampshire, Massachusetts, Connecticut, Rhode Island: Over $150 Free, Otherwise $35 New York-New Jersey: Over $200 Free, Otherwise $45 Pennsylvania, Delaware, Maryland, District of Columbia, Virginia, North Carolina, South Carolina, Georgia, Ohio, West Virginia, Tennessee, Alabama, Michigan, Indiana, Kentucky, Wisconsin, Illinois, Minnesota, Iowa, Missouri: Over $300 Free, Otherwise $65 Florida, California, Oregon, Washington, Idaho, Nevada, Idaho, Utah, Arizona, Montana, Wyoming, Colorado, New Mexico, North Dakota, South Dakota, Nebraska, Kansas, Oklahoma, Texas, Arkansas, Louisiana, Mississippi: Over $375 Free, Otherwise $80
Seafood RangeMaine Bluefin Tuna, Wild-Caught Atlantic Halibut Fillet, Wild-Caught Swordfish Steaks, Maine Bluefin Tuna TORO (Belly), Fore Islands Atlantic Salmon Fillets, Gulf of Maine Haddock Fillets, Gulf of Maine Cod Fillets, Gulf of Maine Monkfish, Maine Butterflied Eel, Carolina Caught Bigeye Ahi Tuna, Wild-Caught Maine Sockeye Salmon, Wild-Caught Shrimp, Domestic Squid, Maine Lobster & Lobster Tails, Smoked Maine Eel, Amaebi Shrimp, Maine Crab Meat, Maine Oysters, Maine Sea Scallops, Jumbo Sea Scallops, Wild-Caught Gulf Shrimp, Siberian Caviar, American White Sturgeon Caviar, Hackleback Caviar, Spoonbill Caviar, Wild Alaskan Salmon Roe, Wild American Bowfin Caviar, Sea Urchin Roe

The quality of the seafood supplied by SOPO Seafood straight out of Portland, Maine, is nothing short of outstanding. It’s a fish and seafood stockist working straight off the waterfront who over-delivers on every aspect of business. Customers are even surprised with a little extra on their first order. From insulated ice packs for better, longer cooling to seafood quality that’s second-to-none and future-dated ordering, SOPO has it all. Overnight delivery available nationwide across the US rewards customers with fresh, delicious restaurant-quality fish that have the least bones you’ll find anywhere, if any at all, species dependent. Shopping online offers similar conveniences to an in-person market, so be on the lookout for gift boxes, caviar kits, and other products like oyster shucking kits geared towards seafood lovers. 

Freshness reigns supreme over SOPO Seafood’s entire line. This is largely the reason for it being named the best place to buy seafood online. Customers won’t necessarily find the variety of other stockists, but the fish and seafood are out of this world. Ordering shellfish like scallops or Maine oysters is sure to surprise, arriving so fresh that there’s no lingering potent fishy odor tainting one’s kitchen leftover after cooking whatsoever. Even customer service matches the high bar set by the carefully handled fresh seafood. Expect attentive touches like being called personally when goods are out of stock and other logistical mishaps and issues. It doesn’t matter what you’re ordering and whether it’s fresh or flash-frozen, you’re sure to be blown away by SOPO’s quality and general approach to seafood delivery. 

Peskados

Regions ServedLocal Same Day Delivery in Miami-Dade & South Broward, Next Day Shipping Nationwide 
DeliveryNo Tracking – Noon Deliveries On Average
SmellSlightly Fishy Outer Odor
FlavorClean & Fresh
Customer ServiceAttentive Support With Follow-Ups On Orders
AffordabilityModerate
ShippingFlorida: Free Shipping On Orders of $100+ Otherwise $15Mississippi, Alabama, Georgia, South Carolina: Free Shipping On Orders Of $195+ Otherwise Orders Of $65-$139.99 @ $49 & Orders Of $140-$194.99 @ $39Texas, Louisiana, Tennessee, Illinois, Kentucky, West Virginia, Virginia, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina: Free Shipping On Orders Of $195+ Otherwise Orders Of $65-$139.99 @ $59 & Orders Of $140-$194.99 @ $49Nebraska, Iowa, Kansas, Missouri, Oklahoma, Arkansas, Indiana, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Maryland, Delaware, Massachusetts, Connecticut, Rhode Island, Vermont, New Hampshire, Maine:  Free Shipping On Orders Of $225+ Otherwise Orders Of $65-$139.99 @ $65 & Orders Of $140-$224.99 @ $55New Mexico, Arizona, California, Colorado, Utah, Nevada, Oregon, Idaho, Wyoming, Washington, Montana, North Dakota, South Dakota, Minnesota, Wisconsin, Michigan: Free Shipping On Orders Of $250+ Otherwise Orders Of $65-$139.99 @ 69 & Orders Of $140-$249.99 @ $58Alaska: Free Shipping On Orders Of $320+ Otherwise Orders Of $65-139.99 @ $120 & Orders Of $140-319.99 @ $90Hawaii (Honolulu): Free Next Business Day Shipping On Orders Of $320+ Otherwise Orders Of $65-139.99 $120 & Orders Of $140-$249.99 @ $90 | Free 2nd Business Day Shipping On Orders Of $250+ Otherwise Orders Of $65-139.99 @ $59 & Orders Of $140-$249.99 @ $39
Seafood RangeYellow Edge Grouper, Wild Red Grouper, Wild Black Grouper, Ocean Trout, Wild Flounder, Wild Corvina, Wild Hog Snapper, Wild Yellow Eye Snapper, Wild Lane Snapper, Kinmedia Alfonsino, Scottish Salmon, Wild John Dory, Wild Withing Hake Merluza, Wild Wahoo, Rainbow Trout, Tilapia, Dover Sole, Wild Yellowtail Snapper, Wild American Red Snapper, Wild Red Snapper, Wild Striped Horse Mackerel, Wild Sea Bream Madai, Seabream Dorada, Wild Chilean Sea Bass, Ora King Salmon, Norwegian Salmon, Coho Salmon, Verlasso Salmon, King Salmon, Wild Mackerel, Wild Mahi, Wild Kanpachi Amberjack, Hamachi Yellowtail, Hiramasa Yellowtail, Wild Halibut, Wild Black Cod, Branzino

Whether ordering salmon, trout, or anything else, customers will undoubtedly be impressed by the Medley, Florida-based fresh and frozen fish market, Peskados. Vacuum-packed whole fish and fish fillets arrive packaged in ice, and the freshness leaves no inner odor, just a slightly fishy smell on the outside. From the moment that it arrives, it’s apparent that everything is exceptionally clean and filets are handled with care. It’s exactly what one would hope for from a sushi fish stockist. This is also the number one place to buy Verlasso salmon in terms of both affordability and balance of quality. There’s nothing to criticize about any item from their range, actually, but this is one of the best varieties of farm-raised salmon one can find, with a buttery texture and light flavor that’s second to none. 

In addition to more fish and fish cuts than you’ll find at most places, there are also subscription boxes and grilling kits like salmon skewers and the like waiting. Although a reliable supplier of affordably-priced seafood, Peskados is not without a few problems, but none are game-breaking. The lack of on-site delivery tracking is a sure-fire trigger for frustration, but despite this annoyance, multiple orders have shown up around noon like clockwork. Customer support could be quicker via email and online channels, but telephonic support is there, and orders ship quickly. A generous customer rewards program makes Peskados an attractive option for those who see themselves ordering frequently. After all, the quality is enough to bring almost anyone back.

Fulton Fish Market

Regions ServedFree Delivery In Connecticut, Delaware, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Vermont, Virginia, Washington D.C. | Nationwide Shipping Across The USA
DeliveryFedEx Tracking With Reliable Overnight Delivery
SmellLow To Mild Outer Smell
FlavorClean Fresh Flavor
Customer ServiceAttentive Customer Service With Telephonic Assistance
AffordabilityModerate
ShippingFree Nationwide Shipping For Frozen Seafood On Orders Of $125+
Seafood RangeAtlantic Salmon, Wild Dry Sea Scallops, Cold Water Wild Lobster, Wild Ahi Tuna, Wild Colossal Blue Shrimp, Branzino, Wild Atlantic Cod, Wild Swordfish, Wild Halibut, King Salmon, East Coast Oysters, PEI Mussels, Wild White Gulf Shrimp, Littleneck Clams, Wild Squid, Rainbow Trout, Wild Salmon Roe, Steamer Clams, Beau Soleil Oysters, Cherrystone Clams, Wild Alaska Salmon, Wild Porgy, Wild American Red Snapper, Wild Spanish Octopus, Wild Hackleback Caviar, Wild Cold Water Lobster, Wild Paddlefish Caviar, Whiting, Wild West Coast Uni Roe, Osetra Caviar, Ventresca Yellowfin Tuna, California White Sturgeon Caviar, Trout Roe, Wild West Coast Uni, Wild West Coast Hokkaido Shoyu Ikura, Hybrid Sturgeon Caviar, Whole Anchovies, Golden King Crab, Wild Colossal Blue Shrimp, Wild Chilean Sea Bass, Arctic Char, King Salmon, Wild Blackfish (Tautog)

Since 1822, Fulton Fish Market has been a popular supplier of fresh seafood to the United States and remains one of the foremost retailers in New York. Fresh, cooked, frozen, live, salted, and smoked seafood of the highest quality are all available nationwide. As the second largest fish market in the world, the selection of fish and other seafood offers more variety than almost all other retailers. It is one of only places to find rare options like blowfish or bottarga, otherwise known as Mediterranean caviar. There are both farmed and wild-caught fish available. Seafood is sourced from all around the world, and each product clearly states the region it originates from. 

Deliveries arrived packed in layered ice packs, which are largely reported to remain completely frozen upon arrival. Fulton Fish Market boasts exceptionally clean fish and shellfish. Fish arrives fresh, and products like clams arrive free from any sand and debris without any cracked shells. While pricing is on par with what one would expect from the average high-end market, seafood bundles offer particularly good value, as do the subscription packages, which provide a 5 % discount by standard. Thousands of positive reviews back this high-end reasonably priced fish markets quality and service and first-hand testing confirms exceptional seafood overall. 

Giovanni’s Fish Market & Galley

Regions ServedNationwide, Discounted Inside Of California
Delivery Superbly Easy To Track
SmellNoticeable Outer Fishy Odor But Fish Flesh/Filets Clean
FlavorImpeccably Fresh, Clean Taste
Customer ServiceRapid Response – Excellent Service
AffordabilityVery High
ShippingNo Free Shipping OfferedWithin California: $29.99 to $199.99 (Weight Dependent, 10 Pound Increments)Outside California:  $49.99 to $299.99 (Weight Dependent, 10 Pound Increments)
Seafood RangeYellowtail, Pacific Red Snapper, White Sea Bass, True Cod, Thresher Shark, Swordfish, Steelhead Trout, Sand Dabs, Sablefish (Black Cod), Petrale Sole, Pacific Halibut, Orange Roughy, Opah, Ono aka Wahoo, Monkfish, Mahi Mahi “Dorado”, Louvar, Lingcod, King Salmon, Hamachi Yellowtail, Grouper, Flounder, Escolar, Coho Salmon, California Halibut, Bigeye Tuna, Albacore Tuna, Alaskan Halibut, Alaskan Cod, Ahi Tuna, Live Abalone, King Crab, Dungeness Crab, Rock Crab, Snow Crab, Blue Crab, Alaska King Crab, King Crab Merus, Diver Scallops, Bay Scallops, Black Mussels, Manila Clams, Razor Clams, EBI Shrimp, Brazilian Lobster, Australian Lobster, Maine Lobster, Pacific Oysters, Grassy Bar Oysters, Blue Point Oysters, Kumamoto Oysters, Pacific Gold Oysters

Giovanni’s Fish Market is a Morro Bay-based supplier of fresh seafood, inclusive of some of the best salmon you’ll find anywhere. Fillets, whole fish, and smoked fish are all kept in stock. The company runs frequent specials that typically change on a weekly basis. Orders arrive fresher than from almost anywhere else, and the quality of everything from the meat itself to pre-prepared delicacies like clam chowder is superb. After all, Giovanni’s is the six-time winner of the Morro Bay Annual Chowder Cook-Off, so expect menu items that are nothing short of exceptional. 

Customers can expect a few bones depending on what fish is being ordered, but they’re large enough to avoid or remove with ease. With a truly massive selection, fair, affordable pricing throughout the range, and one of the best order tracking systems encountered, Giovanni’s is one of the best seafood suppliers in the US. Orders are shipped faster than most expect, even from a high-efficiency supplier, but the fish is, however, only packed in ice alone. In spite of this, testing revealed a slight odor on the outside of the packaging alone. All goods arrive ultra-fresh. 

Amazon Fresh

Regions Served38+ States
Delivery Basic But Effective Tracking
SmellLow To Light Fishiness
FlavorClean, Fresh Taste
Customer ServiceMediocre But Reliable
AffordabilityHigh
ShippingFree Shipping On Orders Of $150+ For Prime MembersNon-Prime Shipping Charge $7.95 to $13.95Prime Shipping Charge $3.95 to $9.95
Seafood RangeFresh Farm Raised MOWI Atlantic Salmon, Fresh  Farm Raised Tilapia, Fresh Farm Raised Atlantic Salmon, Fresh Wild Caught Sockeye Salmon, Fresh Wild Caught Pacific Cod, Fresh Farm Raised Steelhead Trout, Fresh Shrimp, Frozen Wild Caught Haddock, Frozen Wild Caught Swordfish, Frozen Wild Caught Yellowfin Tuna, Frozen Wild Caught Pacific Whiting, Frozen Wild Caught Pacific Cod, Frozen Tilapia

AmazonFresh, a subsidiary of the e-commerce giant Amazon, has ventured into the domain of grocery delivery, and the company’s seafood is of consistently good quality. An impressive range of seafood, from the commonplace to the exotic, is on offer. From the farm-raised Mowi salmon to Marine Harvest trout and tilapia, the flavor is clean and fresh, with very few bones. Impeccable service across the board, from shipping to customer service and delivery of quality seafood, is to be expected. Amazon really is incredible. The precise logistics, synonymous with Amazon’s overarching operational prowess, ensures that every piece of seafood reaches the consumer in peak condition.

While the seafood is impeccably packaged to retain freshness – often with ample ice packs or refrigerated pouches – the sheer amount of plastic and non-biodegradable material utilized often raises eyebrows. On the brighter side, AmazonFresh does make an effort to source sustainable seafood. Expect highly affordable fish that need very little cleaning, if any at all, to come out tasting great. Though the conversation about packaging presents a valid concern, it’s the brand’s dedication towards ensuring the delivery of pristinely fresh seafood that steals the spotlight, often drawing attention to the quality within rather than the external packaging. With a customer-centric approach that veers towards offering variety and affordability, AmazonFresh continues to carve out its niche in the online seafood market, presenting a convenient and reliably fresh option.

All Fresh Seafood

Regions ServedDiscounted Shipping Throughout Midwest & Southwest USA | Nationwide Overnight Shipping Available
DeliveryOrders Ship Within 48-Hours – Tracking Via UPS
SmellMildly Fishy Smell
FlavorMostly Fresh With Infrequent Textural Issues
Customer ServiceHighly Responsive Customer Service With Telephonic Ordering Offered
AffordabilityModerate
ShippingNew York State, New Jersey, Marland, Delaware, Massachusetts, Connecticut & Pennsylvania: Free Delivery On Orders Of $149+ Otherwise $22.99 For Orders Under $149 Virginia, Vermont & New Hampshire: Free Delivery On Orders Over $149 Otherwise  $34.99 For Orders Under $149Maine, West Virginia, North Carolina, South Carolina, Georgia, Alabama, Tennessee, Kentucky, Indiana, Missouri, Iowa, Minnesota, Wisconsin, Illinois, Michigan, Indiana, Ohio, West Virginia: Free Delivery On Orders Of $149+ Otherwise $49.99 For Orders Under $149Alaska: $35 Delivery On Orders Of $149+ Otherwise $85 For Orders Under $149zBJ/ujh Rest Of US: Free Delivery On Orders Over $149 Otherwise $49.99 For Orders Under $149
Seafood RangeAtlantic Salmon, Baccala (Cod), Wild Caught Black Sea Bass, Farm Raised Branzino, Mediterranean Branzino, Wild Caught Chilean Sea Bass, Wild-Sockeye Salmon, Faroe Island Salmon, Arctic Char, Farmed Black Sea Bass, Domestic Swordfish, Icelandic Cod, Norwegian Salmon, Red Snapper, Tilapia, Grey Sole, Wild Caught Halibut, Wild Caught Boston Mackerel, Wild Caught Spanish Mackerel, Wild Caught Sardines, Wild Caught Peruvian Smelts, Idaho Rainbow Trout, Farmed King Salmon, Wild Caught Lemon Sole, Wild Caught Mahi-Mahi, Monkfish, Wild Caught New England Haddock, Octopus, Pompano, Wild Florida Red Snapper, Ruby Red Trout, Wild Portuguese Sardines, Farmed Scottish Salmon, Wild Caught Sushi Fluke, Wild Caught Walleye Pike, Wild Alaska Coho Salmon, Ahi Yellowfin Tuna, Colossal King Crab, Maryland Crab, Blue Point Oysters, Chesapeake Bay Blue Point Oysters, Squid, Farmed Shrimp, North Carolina Wild Shrimp, Maine Lobster, Diver Scallops, Florida Stone Crab, Cold Water Maine Lobster Oreganata, Wild Caught Maine Steamer Clams, PEI Mussels, Rhode Island Littleneck Clams, Canadian Snow Crab, South African Lobster, American Sturgeon Hackleback Caviar, Per Se Caviar, Trout Roe Caviar, Salmon Roe Caviar, Siberian Osetra Caviar, Royal Osetra Caviar, Kaluga Caviar

At All Fresh Seafood, customers can expect to pay a higher-than-average premium, but for this, you’re rewarded with superior freshness and overall quality across a mammoth selection of goods. While the entire considerably expansive range presents a consistently good standard, the company is famous for its crab and lobster meat. Customers generally report fresh, low-odor fish; everything is loosely packed in ice, and orders often need thorough rinsing. With this being said, one finds nothing but rave reviews reporting superior shellfish at a fairly high cost – a fee most find well worth the expenditure when sampling the quality. 

In addition to fresh, frozen, and smoked fish and shellfish, there are also premade dumplings, black angus, pork, lamb, veal, burgers & hotdogs, and poultry available, which means that the combo boxes offer considerable value. There are also subscription boxes, chef’s picks, weekly specials, and generous rewards programs. All Fresh Seafood is fond of combining extra pounds of fish and certain types of other seafood for free when ordering above a particular threshold. For example, a frequent promotion features paying for two pounds of lobster meat and getting another pound at a half-off discount. There are tons of these types of deals to be found.

Pure Food Fish Market

Regions ServedDiscounted Overnight Shipping For Washington & Oregon | Nationwide Shipping Available
DeliveryAccurate On-Site Order Tracking With Ongoing Email Updates
SmellLow To No Odor
FlavorRich, Supremely Clean, Buttery & Fresh
Customer ServiceFriendly Helpful Prompt Customer Service 
AffordabilityModerate
Shipping$60 Flat Rate For FedEX Overnight Shipping Within Continental USA | $80 Shipping For Alaska & Hawaii 
Seafood RangeWild Caught Coho Salmon, Wild Caught Alaskan Sockeye Salmon, Northwest King Salmon, Alaskan White King Salmon, Wild Caught Copper River King Salmon, Wild Red Salmon Caviar, Wild Halibut, Smoked Salmon, Kumomoto Oysters, Hood Canal Oysters, Mussels, Manila Steamer Clams, Shigoku Oysters, Quillcene Oysters, Smoked Mussels, Wild Jumbo Scallops, Bay Scallops, Smoked Scallops, Jumbo Shrimp, Jumbo Shrimp Scampi, Salad Shrimp, White Gulf Shrimp, Pacific Razor Clams, Dungeness Crab, King Crab, Red King Crab, Alaskan Snow Crab, Alaskan Bairdi Crab, Lobster, Sea Urchin “Uni”

Pure Food Fish Market is a premier stockist of high-end seafood nestled in the world-famous Pike Place Market in Seattle. Pike Place Market is a vibrant and iconic treasure nestled in the heart of Seattle, and it’s nothing short of a culinary paradise accepting of only the most devoted retailers and artisanal stores. It’s premium fish and shellfish at premier prices, but you really get what you pay for. In fact, Pure Food Fish Market is regarded to be the best in the center itself. As a store that’s been a popular favorite since 1911, customers can expect amazing quality with slightly higher-than-average pricing. Although customers are sure to be impressed by the range, the selection of smoked fish is particularly broad. 

Anyone who’s been to the brick-and-mortar store knows all too well just how high the demand is, making online ordering an attractive option even for those in the vicinity. Ice packs are used to keep shipments fresh, and the packaging works. Handling procedures are very tight, resulting in extremely clean fish. Service is friendly and prompt regardless of whether or not you’re buying in person or online. Furthermore, every dollar spent builds rewards a point when opting into the rewards program, which is a boon for frequent shoppers. If you’re willing to pay for quality, Pure Food Fish Market may be the ideal stockist for you. 

Harbor Fish Market

Regions ServedLocal Pickup In Portland | Local Delivery @ $10 For Orders Of $100+ in Portland, South Portland, Cape Elizabeth, Scarborough, Falmouth, Yarmouth, Cumberland Foreside | Nationwide Shipping Available
DeliveryFedEx Priority Overnight or UPS Next Day With Courier Tracking – Order Arrive Between 8:30 And Noon
SmellLow/ Fishy Odor Only Outer Smell 
FlavorFlavorful Ocean-Fresh Taste – Exceptionally Clean
Customer ServiceFriendly Online & Telephonic Support
AffordabilityHigh
ShippingNo Free Shipping Offered, Standard FedEx Rates Apply (Weight & Distance Dependent)
Seafood RangeNorth Atlantic Salmon, Haddock, Halibut, Swordfish, Yellowfin Tuna, Cod, Grey Sole, Arctic Char, Flounder, Hake, Wild Pacific Salmon, Sushi-Grade Bluefin Tuna, Branzini, Pollock, Monkfish, Halibut, Rainbow Trout, Red Snapper, Mackerel, Bluefish, Wild Black Sea Bass, Squid, Snapper, Hybrid Bass, Anchovies, Cusk, Smelts, Opah (Moonfish), Butterfish, Maine Lobster, Maine Steamers, Hard Shell Clams, Scallops, Rope-Grown Maine Mussels, Soft Shell Crab, Clams, Oysters, Alaskan King Crabs, Donostia Clams, Mahogany Clams, Cockles, Razor Clams

With two locations in Portland and Scarborough, Harbor Fish Market is easily one of the most affordable fish markets in the country. The ultra-low prices will undoubtedly wow prospective customers, and all will be happy to know that the quality is there, too. After all, the site itself has been a fish market since the 1800s, and the business as we know it today has been proudly family-owned since 1966. Customers can expect well-handled fish with little to no bones, depending on the species. Specific cuts, such as those of salmon, explicitly state that the pin bones have been removed. 

From responsive customer service to attentive handling and some of the lowest prices you’ll find anywhere, Harbor Fish Market has it all. Don’t let the sluggish speed of the site deter you from checking out what they have to offer, for there’s immense value on some of the finest seafood Maine has available waiting. In addition to excellent fresh and frozen seafood, Harbor Fish Market also carries a limited selection of cooked food (including cooked lobster), seasonings, condiments, kitchen equipment suited to seafood preparation, and some canned goods. Those in the immediate vicinity certainly won’t be disappointed, with reliable nationwide shipping also available. 

Four Star Seafood and Provisions

Regions ServedFree Local Pickup In San Francisco | Nationwide Shipping Available
DeliveryFedEx Tracker
SmellLow To No Fishy Odor
FlavorImpeccably Fresh Clean Flavor
Customer ServiceCustomer Service With Dedicated Support Agent (Telephonic & Online)
AffordabilityLow
ShippingFree Shipping On Orders of $100+ In SF Bay Area$45 Flat Shipping Rate Within California$100 Flat Shipping Rate Outside Of California
Seafood RangeAlbacore Four Star Tuna, San Francisco Bay Anchovies, New Zealand Big Glory Bay King Salmon, California Black Cod, Virginia Blowfish Tails, Greek Branzino, Korean Chilean Sea Bass, Wild Sockeye Salmon, Moroccan European Eel, Alaskan Halibut, Norwegian Halibut, Sushi-Grade Engawa Halibut, Sushi-Grade San Francisco Bay Halibut, Sushi-Grade Japanese Hamachi, New Zealand Hawaiian Swordfish, Australian Hiramasa, Panama Kampachi, Fort Bragg Ling Cod, California Wild Black Cod (Sablefish), Scottish Loch Duart Salmon, Ecuador Mahi, Massachusetts Monkfish, Sushi-Grade New Zealand Ora King Salmon, Oregon Petrale Sole, Sushi-Grade New Zealand Red Sea Bream, New Zealand, Red Sea Bream, Monterey Rockfish, British Columbian Atlantic Salmon, Northern California Sand Dabs, Greek Sea Bream (Dorade), Massachusetts Skate, Moroccan European Eel, California Sturgeon, Mt. Lassen Farmed Trout, Baja Californian Striped Bass, Sushi-Grade South Pacific Yellowfin Tuna, Spanish Turbot, Chilipepper Rockfish, Washington BBQ Oysters, New Brunswick Beausoleil Oysters, British Columbia Kusshi Oysters, Port Reyes Miyahi Oysters, Washington Royal Miyagi Oysters, Duxbury Standish Shore Oysters, California Abalone, Argentinian Red Shrimp, British Columbia Spot Prawns, Maine Lobster, Dungeness Crab, Galveston Gulf Shrimp, Costa Rica Sustainable Laughing Bird Shrimp, Florida Littleneck Clams, East Coast Scallops, Maine Lobster, Hood Canal Manila Clams, Spanish Octopus, Oregon Shrimp, Prince Edward Island Mussels, Sushi-Grade Holland Razor Clams, British Columbia Salt Spring Mussels, Washington Blue Shell Savory Clams, Mexican Shrimp, Maine Scallops, West Coast Uni, Monterey Whelks, White Sturgeon Caviar, Paddlefish Caviar, Salmon Roe, Trout Roe, Don Bocarte Boquerones, Don Bocarte Anchovies, Bottarge Dell’lsola, Smoked Steelhead

Four Star Seafood and Provisions provides a convenient solution for seafood enthusiasts, offering the ease of overnight delivery six days a week from San Francisco. Their product selection is nothing short of impressive, catering to a wide range of tastes and preferences. Whether you’re in the mood for the exquisite freshness of sashimi-grade tuna or the delightful simplicity of a popular favorite like branzino or King salmon, you’ll find it here. The store is committed to diversity, going beyond the ordinary to offer more exotic options like Spanish octopus and the intriguingly unique flying fish roe. Moreover, their dedication to keeping prices reasonable ensures that enjoying high-quality seafood doesn’t have to break the bank.

Instead of ice or ice packs, Four Star Seafood and Provisions packs deliveries in reusable gel packs, which customers can either keep and use for their own applications or return with their next order if so preferred. Local deliveries in the San Francisco Bay area arrive in a refrigerated truck, thereby ensuring optimal freshness. Customer service is a step above most competing stores, with both the chefs and a dedicated customer support agent ready to help almost all day, all week. If you’re angling for fresh fish in the Bay Area, this is one market that certainly won’t disappoint. 

Peter’s Florida Seafood

Regions ServedLocal Delivery In Florida | Nationwide Shipping Available
DeliveryNext Day Delivery
SmellUltra-Fresh, Low Odor
FlavorOcean Fresh, Very Clean
Customer ServicePersonal Customer Service Via Phone, Email & Online Form
AffordabilityVery Low
ShippingFree Nationwide Next-Day Shipping for Orders over $200
Seafood RangeFaroe Islands Scottish Salmon, Mahi-Mahi, Alaskan Halibut, Yellowtail Snapper, Black Grouper, Australian Barramundi, Atlantic Swordfish, Sashimi Grade Ahi Tuna, Red Snapper, Yellowtail Snapper, Branzino, Octopus, Chilean Sea Bass, Key West Pink Shrimp, Florida Lobster, Atlantic Sea Scallops, Florida Royal Red Shrimp, Stone Crab Claws

Fish from Peter’s Florida Seafood market is all fresh and sourced from sustainable suppliers. Previously operating under the name Francesca’s Favorites, the company underwent a strategic rebranding to align its core focus exclusively on the world of fish. Notably, the founder and CEO of this establishment actively serves as a board member of the Southeastern Fisheries Association, a reputable body dedicated to the responsible and sustainable harvesting of aquatic resources by commercial institutions. At Peter’s, the attention to detail in sourcing is paramount. Every fish offered is hand-selected by their skilled fishmongers, resulting in the freshest, highest quality Caribbean and Florida-waters seafood you’ll find anywhere. 

Fish is shipped shrink-wrapped in reusable insulated packaging with reusable gel packs instead of slap-standard ice or ice packs. After arrival, they’re set to last roughly four days in the fridge. Customers may notice a strong fishy smell on the outside of the wrapping and upon the ice packs, but the inner freshness of the flesh is superb. Peter’s offers three seafood packages bundling fish and shellfish, which brings down the already-affordable cost of its products even more. Peter’s Florida Seafood doesn’t have a social media presence, but keep an eye on their website for frequent promotions and to know what the catch of the day is for the freshest freshness possible.

Santa Barbara Fish Market

Regions ServedFree Local Pickup In Santa Barbara | Nationwide Shipping Available
DeliveryLocal Delivery Available | FedEX Tracking – Overnight Shipping 
SmellLow To No Fishy Odor
FlavorExemplary Flavor And Clean Freshnes
Customer ServiceAssertive Customer Service
AffordabilityModerate
Shipping Free Next Day Home Delivery For Order Of $40+ Within Santa Barbara, Next Day Delivery Via FedEx – Variable Charge Based On Distance, Retail Market Pickup Also Available For Orders Of $40+
Seafood RangeLocal Channel Island Rockfish, San Diego Bluefin Tuna, Local Big Eye Ahi Tuna, Black Cod (Sable Fish), Santa Barbara Hook Caught Halibut, Swordfish, Scottish Salmon, New Zealand Ora King Salmon, Atlantic Salmon, Ocean Trout (Steelhead), Albacore Tuna, Pacific Yellowtail, Branzino, Santa Barbara Vermilion Rockfish, Wild Northern Halibut, Petrale Sole, Ono (Wahoo), Mahi Mahi, Opah, Corvina Sea Bass, Lingcod, Pacific Rockfish, Yellowtail Rockfish, White Shrimp, Bay Scallops, Blue Point Oysters, Buckley Bay Oysters, Calamari, Coast Crab, Farmed White Shrimp, Kumiai Oysters, Littleneck Clams, Maine Lobster, Manila Clams, Santa Barbara Rock (Stone) Crab, Santa Barbara Sea Urchin, Wild Mexican Shrimp, Soft Shell Crab, Wild White Del Pacifico Shrimp, Wild Sea Scallops, Wild EZ Peel Shrimp

For over two decades, the Santa Barbara Fish Market has been favored by droves of locals. In fact, among its many awards, the establishment received the illustrious Best of Santa Barbara title by means of a reader’s poll in a leading local publication in both 2021 and 2022, which is a key indication of the quality to expect. It’s amazing restaurant-quality fish at mid-range grocery store prices. Weekly specials present even greater affordability, as do the seafood boxes. Those in the vicinity can take advantage of either the local pickup or drive-thru service, while shoppers online receive overnight delivery on all orders. 

While the fresh fresh boasts unquestionable freshness and flavor, frozen shellfish reportedly don’t always reach this lofty standard. With this being said, even when shellfish arrive requiring extra cleaning, the taste is always ocean-fresh. Santa Barbara Fish Market is also one of the best places to shop for uni, with customers across the board praising its quality. All shipments are packed using what their company calls ‘renewliner’ packs, which are made from recycled water bottles, which are far more eco-friendly than most competitors.

King Tide Seafood Provisions

Regions ServedNationwide Delivery
DeliveryPriority Overnight Or Next Day UPS With UPS Online Tracking
SmellMild To Low General Fishiness
FlavorReasonably Fresh Flavor With Clean Flavor Profile
Customer ServiceEmail Support With 3 Day Query Window For Refunds (Spoiled Goods Only)
AffordabilityModerate
ShippingNo Free Shipping ThresholdStandard UPS Rates Apply
Seafood RangeLake Erie Walleye, Lake Erie Yellow Perch, Smelts, Atlantic Salmon, Ora King Salmon, St. James Scotch Reserve Salmon, Verlasso Salmon, Wild Sockeye Salmon, Chilean Sea Bass, Gulf Red Grouper, Atlantic Halibut, Icelandic Cod, Ocean Perch, Octopus, Northern Atlantic Scallops, American Gulf Red Snapper, North Atlantic Sole, Squid, Swordfish, Arctic Char, Riverence Steelhead, Tilapia, Rainbow Trout, Crawfish, Jonah Crab, King Crab, Atlantic Lobster, Bahamas Lobster, Oishii EZ Peel Shrimp, Scampis 6/8, Wild Gulf White Shrimp

King Tide Seafood Provisions ships hand-cut fillets of fresh, sustainably harvested fish across the country from Daniel Island in South Carolina. Seafood is sourced from hand-picked suppliers in New Zealand, Vancouver, Thailand, Portland, Maine, Eastern Virginia’s coast, and the Great Lakes. All fish is deboned as far as possible, leaving nothing but pin bones and certain others in specific varieties of fish like Lake Erie Yellow Perch. The quality of handling is better than most, and pricing is generally very affordable. It’s a never-frozen specialist with a rather small selection compared to some fish markets, but the quality is pretty close to infallible.

Prospective customers should know that they’ll be asked to buy four fillets at a time when ordering most fish, but the value of these two-pound packages is surprising. While King Tide Seafood Provisions offers a varying range of fish, including wild-caught and shellfish, at good prices, it’s the farmed fish and lake fish that are exceptionally well-priced. The intimate selection, rather than being a limitation, assures customers of the brand’s dedication to maintaining superior freshness.

Anderson Seafoods

Regions ServedNationwide Shipping Available (Continental US Only)
DeliveryEasy Functional On-Site Order Tracking
SmellMinimal Fishiness In Outer Packaging To No Odor
FlavorOcean Fresh With Superb Flavor
Customer ServiceDedicated Telephonic Customer Service, Social Media & Email Support Also Available
AffordabilityHigh
Fresh Shipping ThresholdFree Shipping On Orders Of $250+ Otherwise All Others $59 Flat Rate Charged
Seafood RangeLake Superior Whitefish, European Sea Bass, Petrale Sole, Tasmanian Ocean Trout, Albacore Tuna, Mahi-Mahi, Swordfish, Yellowfin Ahi Tuna, Copper River Sockeye Salmon, Crab Meat, Fijian Opah, Scottish Salmon, Atlantic Salmon, Alaskan Halibut, Fijian Ono (Wahoo), Yellowtail, Striped Sea Bass, Troll Caught Wild King Salmon, Mount Cook Alpine Saikou King Salmon, Pacific Rockfish, Idaho Rainbow Trout, Ruby Red Rainbow Trout, Arctic Char, Tai Snapper (Pink Sea Bream), Alaskan Black Cod (Sablefish), Pacific White Seabass, Hiramasa, Chilean Sea Bass, Florida Stone Crab, Corvina, Steelhead Trout, Tilapia, Catfish, King Salmon (Chinook), Baquetta Sea Bass, Wild King Salmon, Wild Mexican Shrimp, California Spiny Lobster, North Atlantic Lobster, Maine Lobster, Tristan Cold Water Rock Lobster, Snow Crab, Alaskan King Crab, Red King Crab, Dungeness Crab, Florida Stone Crab, Osetra Caviar, Sevruga Caviar, Sturgeon Caviar, Bowfin (North American) Caviar, Salmon Roe (Ikura, Israeli Osetra Caviar (Karat Caviar), French Sturgeon Caviar, Siberian Caviar, Scallops, Smoked Alaskan Scallops, Abalone

Anderson Seafoods is a fresh seafood wholesaler based in Anaheim that offers highly competitive rates on fresh and frozen seafood to retail customers as well. Regardless of which customers opt for, the quality is reliably good with low fishiness, and all products are sustainably sourced. Shipments are packed with ice packs and dry ice, ensuring that customers receive ocean-fresh fish and shellfish. The company keeps fish and other seafood from Mexico, Hawaii, Alaska, Canada, the Pacific Northwest, the East Coast, Asia, and South America, which gives customers a huge variety to choose from. 

Those opting to order from Anderson Seafoods should know that customer service is slightly sluggish, but queries and returns do get attended to. To this day, Anderson Seafoods remains a family-owned and managed business devoted to delivering the freshest seafood possible overnight throughout the US. A clear reflection of this is how it currently stands within the top 2% of all USDC-inspected food companies. There’s every reason to give this company that’s been proudly serving America from Southern California for over forty years. 

Charleston Seafood

Regions ServedNationwide Shipping Available | Discounted Shipping Across South Carolina
DeliveryOrders Before 11AM Same Day Shipping Otherwise Next Day Via FedEx With Courier Tracking
SmellLow Fishiness Within Packaging, Minimal Odor Overall
FlavorClean Flavor With Fresh Texture
Customer ServicePersonal Email & Telephonic Support
AffordabilityModerate
ShippingNo Free Shipping OfferedStandard FedEx Rates Apply (Weight & Distance Dependent)
Seafood RangeBlack Grouper, Catfish, Chilean Sea Bass, Flounder, Halibut, Mahi-Mahi, Rainbow Trout, Red Snapper, Salmon, Swordfish, Sashimi Grade Tuna, Jumbo Shrimp, Rock Shrimp, Alaskan King Crab, Littleneck Clams, Conch, Crab Roe, Crawfish, Cocktail Crab Claws, Mussels, Oysters, Scallops, Snow Crab, Lobster (Regular, Big, Bigger, Biggest, Colossal), Calamari, American Sturgeon Caviar, Black Sturgeon Osetra Caviar, Octopus (Adult, Petite), Smoked Salmon, Smoked Trout

With a narrow but high-quality selection of fish and various other seafood out there and prime freshness matching the diversity of the range, Charleston Seafood is one of the very best fresh fish markets in the Carolinas. Fishmongers cut fillets directly before being shrink-wrapped, packed in frozen gel packs and insulated packaging, and then shipped. Cuts are taken on the day of shipping itself and never in advance. Deliveries are always on time and arrive on the same day if placed before. From the grouper to the shrimp, customers rave over Charlestone’s quality and overall value for money.  

Prices are a little on the high side, but those who are extremely particular about the condition of their fish may find this money well-spent. Charleston Seafood exhibits a great deal of finesse and careful handling. Frugal shoppers should, however, be alert for rotating weekly specials and are advised to check out the combo packs. Charleston fish arrive perfectly deboned. Also, a complete satisfaction guarantee grants complete peace of mind to shoppers by offering the choice of a refund or replacement if they are not happy. For locals in Anchorage, this market is a go-to spot for fresh seafood. It’s not just a place to shop. It’s a community institution that’s become a part of many families’ traditions.

Fresh Catch Fish Co.

Regions ServedNationwide Shipping Available | Local Delivery In Florida
DeliverySame Day Shipping Before Noon, Next Day Shipping After 12 EST | UPS Next Day Air With UPS Tracking
SmellLow To Mild Fishy Smell
FlavorRich Flavor – High To Moderate Freshness
Customer ServiceExceptionally Accommodating Support With Online & Telephonic Help
AffordabilityModerate
ShippingFree Home Delivery Within Southwest Florida On Orders of $99+Standard UPS Rates Apply (Weight & Distance Dependent)
Seafood RangeAmberjack, Wild Argentine Red Shrimp, Black Grouper, Branzino, Catfish, Chilean Sea Bass, Clams, Cobia, Corvina, Dover Sole, Faroe Islands Salmon, Fjord Steelhead Trout, Golden Tilefish, Grouper, Haddock, Halibut, Hogfish, Icelandic Cod, Wild Key West Pink Shrimp, Lane Snapper, Ling Cod, Lobster, Mahi-Mahi, Monkfish, Mussels, Ora King Salmon, Orange Roughy, Pacific Halibut, Pompano, Idaho Rainbow Trout, Red Snapper, Redfish, Rockfish, Scamp Grouper, Sea Scallops, Sheepshead, Snowy Grouper, Sockeye Salmon, South Carolina Flounder, Stone Crabs, Swordfish, Triggerfish, Tripletail, Wahoo, Walleye, Yellow Fin Ahi Tuna, Yellow Tail Snapper

The Fresh Catch Fish Co. is a Punta Gorda-based supplier of seafood, meat, and various preprepared products. All the high-quality seafood is sourced from Florida waters and other regions around the USA. It’s a family-run business that takes great pride in what they do. A massive variety of fresh seafood is on offer, including sushi-grade tuna. A fresh fish list is updated daily, presenting several catch-of-the-day items for those on the hunt for prime freshness. Non-seafood items are carefully selected, which ensures customers’ prime quality throughout the range. 

Even though Fresh Catch Fish Co. carries some of the freshest, highest-quality fish in Southwest Florida, the pricing is amazing. Glance at any of the prices, and you’ll be blown away by the affordability. Furthermore, anyone who stays near enough can take advantage of pre-order discounts and in-store collect-only promos, while all customers should be on the lookout for promotions like frequent sales on frozen seafood and bulk savings. 

Honolulu Fish

Regions ServedFree Nationwide Shipping Available (Excluding Puerto Rico And Alaska, Conditions Apply) | Shipping To Hawaii Also Offered
DeliveryFedEx / UPS Tracking
SmellSuperb Handling With Ultra-Low To No Fishiness
FlavorTender With Ocean Fresh Flavor
Customer ServiceCustomer Support Via Social Media And Email With Sluggish Online Response Time
AffordabilityLow
ShippingFree Shipping On Orders Of $200+Standard FedEx Rates Apply To Orders Of Under $200
Seafood RangeKauai Sweet Prawns U8/U12, Red Deep Sea Sweet Crab, Hawaiian Ahi (Bigeye Tuna), Loch Gourmet Salmon, Izumi-Dai, Scottish Salmon, Hawaiian Bright Red Albacore Ahi (Sashimi), Kona Kampachi Sashimi, Shutome (Sushi Grade Swordfish), Alaskan Hook Caught Halibut, Wild Caught Izumim-Dai, Gourmet White Shrimp, Black Cod Butterfish, Pacific Sashimi Coral Cod, Premium U10 Scallops, Barramundi, Hawaiian Ono, King Salmon, Red Deep Sea Sweet Crab, Opakapaka Snapper, Japanese Hamachi, Mero Sea Bass, Ahi Toro, Monchong (Deep Sea Pomfret)

Maguro-grade tuna doesn’t get better than the various sashimi cuts sold by Honolulu Fish. It’s prime quality fish that’s so good that it’s even suitable for chefs and gourmet restaurants. After all, the company does not support net fishing whatsoever, which means that every last catch is hook caught from within Hawaii waters, and the entire range is sustainable. All fillets except for the four-pound King Salmon cut ship with both their skin and bloodline removed. Customers will find that the degree of cleanliness and delicate handling is superior to almost any other fish market. Those who are looking for the freshest arrivals should keep an eye on the HFC Order Form, which updates with the freshest catches daily. Ordering is per pound only.

We strongly suggest that all interested parties subscribe to the free Ahi Club to receive updates concerning promotions and the availability of fish. Anyone who’s not totally happy with their order simply needs to send it back for a full refund or swap, thanks to the 100% customer satisfaction guarantee. The package is even collected at the company’s expense. Honolulu Fish has been featured by renowned publications like O Magazine, Bon Appetit, and Food & Wine Magazine, to name but a few numerous times. The prices are up there, but the quality is nothing short of the best. Honolulu’s definitely worth a try if you’re a discerning fish lover. 

Citarella Gourmet Market

Regions ServedNationwide Shipping Available | Local Delivery In New York City, Hamptons & Greenwich, CT
DeliveryNext Day Delivery With Tracking Number
SmellExceptionally Clean Handling Results In Low To No Fishy Odor
FlavorSuperior Freshness Results In Clean Pronounced Flavor
Customer ServiceReliable But Variable Customer Support Via Phone, Email & Social Media
AffordabilityLow
ShippingNo Free Shipping Offered
Connecticut, Delaware, District of Columbia, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Vermont, Virginia: $34.99 Flat Rate Shipping Alabama, Illinois, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maine, Michigan, North Carolina, South Carolina, Tennessee: $59.99 Flat Rate ShippingArizona, Arkansas, California, Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Idaho, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Minnesota, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, Nevada. New Mexico, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, South Dakota, Texas, Utah, Washington, West Virginia, Wisconsin, Wyoming: $69.99 Flat Rate Shipping
Seafood RangeArctic Char, Black Cod, Black Sea Bass, Blackfish, Bluefish, Boned Shad, Boston Mackerel, Tuscan Branzino, Organic King Salmon, Catfish, Striped Bass, Cod, Flounder, Fluke, Butterfish, Carp, Coho Salmon, Dover Sole, Eel, Eurpean Anchovies, Grey Sole, Grouper, Haddock, Hake, Halibut, Hybrid Striped Bass, Icelandic Turbot, Sardines, John Dory, King Salmon, Lemon Sole, Mahi Mahi, Monk Fish, New Zealand Red Snapper, Norwegian Salmon, New Zealand Ora King Salmon, Orange Roughy, Orata (Dorade), Pike, Pink Snapper, Plaice, Pompano, Porgies, Rainbow Trout, Red Fish (Red Drum), Red Snapper, Rouget, Sand Dab, Sea Trout, Skate, Smelts, Sockeye Salmon, Spanish Mackerel, Striped Bass, Sworfish, Tasmanian Trout, Tilapia, Tilefish, Tuna, Turbno, Whitefish, Whiting, Bad Boy Oysters, Peconic Oysters, Fishers Island Oysters, Kumamoto Oysters, Lucky Lime Oysters, Wellfleet Oysters, Belon Oysters, Cherrystone Clams, Little Neck Clams, Steamers, New Zealand Cockles, Manila Clams, Razor Clams, Sea Scallops, Nantucket Bay Scallops, Cape Cod Bay Scallops, Prince Edward Island Mussels, Gambero Rosso Shrimp, Madagascar Organic Shrimp, Medium Shrimp, Large Shrimp, Jumbo Shrimp, Rock Shrimp, Lobsters (Small, Large), Cold Water Lobster, Langoustines, East Coast Uni (Shelled Sea Urchin), West Coast Uni, Baby Octopus, Calamari, Baby Sepia, Blowfish Tail, Periwinkles, Scungilli (Conch), Eel, Alasking King Crab, Stone Crab, Marland Crab, Hardshell Crab, Wild Soft Shell Crabs, American Caviar, White Sturgeon Caviar, Osetra Caviar, Beluga Hybrid Caviar, Salmon Roe

Citarella Gourmet Market is one of the oldest fish markets in New York and a leading supplier of some of the freshest, never-frozen fish in the country. Every overnight order is wrapped tightly in wax paper before being shrink-wrapped and then packaged into a leak-proof insulated container with ice packs. Orders are also patted dry before packaging and shipped with drying clothes. As the owner and one of New York City’s original fishmongers explains, not all fish sourced from sustainable local markets are equal freshness. This is why Citarella selects only the freshest fish, which means that customers receive fish that have been on a boat for only a day or two instead of up to an entire week. It’s the best of the Upper East Side available to order online, with remote service delivery on par with the ever-popular brick-and-mortar stores spread across NYC, the Hamptons, and Connecticut.

With this being said, this isn’t the place one shops for sushi-grade fish but rather sustainable high-end whole fish and fillets from all around the world. The transparency from Citarella is great. Shoppers know exactly where their fish comes from and whether it’s farmed or not. In addition to fine seafood, there’s also American, Osetro, Beluga, and White sturgeon caviar available, and the quality is fantastic. A limited selection of steaks, ribs, pork, and burgers are also sold, but these are specially chosen and are truly a notch above what one would commonly find in the best butcheries. There’s even a limited range of high-end specialty items like cuttlefish ink, grated bottarga, and sea urchins sold. Think of Citarella as a one-stop shop for all gourmet seafood, meat, and pantry items. 

10th & M Seafoods

Regions ServedHome Delivery In Anchorage | Nationwide Shipping Available
DeliveryFedEx Priority Overnight With Tracking
SmellMinimally Low Odor To Zero Odor Present, Amazing Handling
FlavorImpeccably Ocean Fresh Flavor With Clean Fillets/Cuts/Whole Fish
Customer ServiceToll Free Telephonic Support, Online Support Via Email & Social Media Also Available
AffordabilityHigh
ShippingNo Free Shipping OfferedStandard FedEx Rates (Weight & Distance Dependent) Apply
Seafood RangeCatfish, Farm Raised Trout, Pacific Oysters, Halibut, Rockfish, Sole, Wild Alaskan King Salmon, Wild Alaskan Sockeye Salmon, Caribbean Lobster, Alaskan True Cod, Crawfish, Dungeness Crab, Black Tiger Shrimp, Halibut, Red King Crab, Scallops, Alaskan Golden King Crab, Codfish, Red Salmon, Silver Salmon, Snow Crab, Sole, Crawfish

10th & M Seafoods delivers friendly, prompt service and fair pricing on fish, shellfish, meat, game, and fish processing services from its store in Anchorage. Veterans should know that a military discount is supplied. The market places a strong emphasis on sustainability, and much of the seafood they offer is wild-caught. As a store serving Alaskans since 1943, it’s better quality than you’ll find almost anywhere else. All seafood is sourced directly from Alaskan waters, ensuring the highest quality. Both fresh and frozen varieties of most of the market’s range are on offer. The company also sells a few other gourmet game delicacies like reindeer sausage and reindeer salami.

If you’re a fan of Alaskan king crab, 10th & M Seafoods is a must-visit. Their king crab legs are renowned for their colossal size and exceptional flavor. Those in Anchorage, Palmer, and Big Lake simply have to sample their menu via the company’s convenient home-delivery service, and all others are urged to consider trying out 10th & M. International shoppers should keep in mind that the shipping of frozen seafood is available and the shipping rates aren’t too bad when considering the quality and scarcity in certain areas of the world. Also, the packing and handling quality is exceptional, featuring vacuum-sealed seafood, which holds up very well even without the ample ice packs and insulated container goods being shipped in. 

.

Keys Fresh Seafood

Regions ServedLocal Delivery In Key West | Nationwide Shipping Available
DeliveryFedEx Overnight With Online Tracking
SmellSupremely Fresh With Minimal Odor
FlavorSuperior Level Of Cleanness & Fresh Favor
Customer ServicePersonal Customer Support Via Live Chat, Contact Form
AffordabilityLow
ShippingNo Free Shipping OfferedStandard FedEx Rates Apply (Weight & Distance Dependent)
Seafood RangeLobster, Stone Crab, Key West Pink Shrimp, Snow Grouper, Barrelfish, Golden Tilefish, Mutton Snapper, Black Grouper, Hogfish, Royal Red Shrimp, Red Grouper, Rosefish, Yellowtail Snapper, Yelloweye Snapper, Queen Snapper, Scamp Grouper, Grey Tilefish, Vermillion Snapper, Yellowedge Grouper, Yellow Jack, Mahi, Trigger Fish, Blackfin Tuna, Red Snapper, Gag Grouper, Yellowfin Tuna, BLackfin Snapper, Kitty Mitchell Grouper, Mangrove Snapper, Wahoo, Swordfish, Tripletail, Rose Porgy, Jolthead Porgy, Lionfish, Lane Snapper, Dog Snapper, Cobia, African Pompano

Key West is famous for its seafood, and among the many excellent fish markets available, Keys Fresh Seafood rises above the competition as the go-to hotspot for locals. The entire range is hook-caught only. Online ordering is available for fresh fish, lobster, shrimp, and stone crab. There’s no sushi tuna like albacore or yellowfin, but everything native to the Florida Keys aquatic realm. You’ll even find invasive but delicious species like lionfish in stock from time to time. The value for money is astounding, but don’t let this deter you, for it’s backed by quality equal to seafood, almost double its price.

All products are backed by a total satisfaction guarantee that does not necessarily require the seafood to be sent back. Returns will be scarce, for Keys Fresh Seafood has an amazing longstanding reputation for the best quality in the area. The only time that you’ll ever get frozen fish or shellfish is when the shellfish is out of season. Even then, good handling ensures low fishiness. Orders are thoughtfully packaged in styrofoam with ice packs, and there are subscription options for those seeking monthly discounts. If you find yourself in Key West, be sure to visit the market for pristine, fresh seafood and an exceptional dining experience.

Captain Marden’s Seafoods

Regions ServedLocal Pickup Only In Massachusetts
DeliveryMobile App Updates For Those Who Order In-App
SmellMild But Fresh Aroma
FlavorLow Fishiness But Generally Very Fresh
Customer ServiceCustomer Support Form & Social Media Only But Highly Attentive Customer Service
AffordabilityHigh
ShippingPickup Only – No Delivery/Shipping Offered
Seafood RangeFarm Raised Wester-Ross Scottish Salmon, Swordfish, Farm Raised Canadian Salmon, Cod, Farm Raised Arctic Char, Halibut, Lemon Sole, Florida Pink Shrimp, Diver Scallops, Grey Sole, Grouper, Mahi Mahi, Squid, Flounder, Farm Raised Bronzini, Red Snapper, Albacore Tuna, Clams, Farm Raised Tilapia, Hake, Rock Shrimp, Smelts, Farmed Kanpachi, Oysters, Black Sea Bass, Lobster, King Crab, Haddock

Captain Marden’s Seafoods is both famous for its fine foods and restaurant situated in Wellesley, Massachusetts. For those ordering online, it’s one of the best fish markets in the region. While a few good quality frozen seafood products like King Crab legs, lobster tails, and frozen prawns are on offer, it’s fresh fish where they excel. A stock list updates each week, presenting popular varieties and exciting rare catches. Expect to find everything from Nova Scotian Halibut and striped bass to Arctic char and farm-raised Scottish salmon waiting at reasonable prices. 

In addition to fresh and frozen seafood with wholesale offerings, Captain Marden’s Seafoods Fish Market also sells steamed and baked lobsters at great rates. However,p this requires calling in advance as kettle space fills up quickly due to the popularity stemming from the superb flavor and affordability. Many, if not most, of the fillets arrive boneless when ordering fish. Fish, shellfish, prepared foods including numerous appetizers, frozen dinners, and even caviar are fairly priced with no compromises to quality and freshness. If you’re in the New England area, we strongly suggest sampling their seafood. 

Fish Finery

Regions ServedNationwide Shipping Available 
DeliveryNext Day Shipping – No Tracking Interface
SmellLow to Non-Existent Fishiness – Ocean Fresh
FlavorFresh, Flavorful & Very Clean
Customer ServiceEmail Only – Responsive & Friendly
AffordabilityLow
ShippingNo Free Shipping Available – Variable Cost Based On Location
Seafood RangeOra King Salmon, Faroe Islands Salmon, Antarctic Salmon, Ahi Tuna, Red Snapper, Mahi-Mahi, Maine Lobster, Grouper, Swordfish, Chilean Sea Bass, Icelandic Cod, Idaho Trout, Black Bass, Fluke, Flounder, Halibut, Alaskan Black Cod, Striped Bass, Monkfish, Farm Raised Branzino, Wild Dover Sole, Wild Turbot, Jumbo Prawns, Jumbo White Shrimp, Mexican Blue Shrimp, Crab, PEI Mussels, Florida Middle Neck Clams, Diver Sea Scallops

Fish Finery is a reliable stockist of high-quality fish filets. In order to ensure the freshest possible fish, customers are advised to place orders preferably three days in advance. If you’re shopping for local catches, northern species of fish, seafood from the Mediterranean, and sushi-grade fillets, this is the ideal gourmet fish market. It’s high-end fish of the finest quality at a considerable cost that’s surprisingly lower than one would expect. The company is so devoted to freshness that it offers a total satisfaction guarantee. If you’re not happy with your purchase in any way, a full refund in credit is granted. 

Considerable value is found in the seasonal boxes that combine various fillets of fish with shellfish. Expect large scallops and exceptionally clean restaurant-quality fish throughout the range. From time to time, they even get in stone crabs. If you’re in South Florida and have a taste for fine, high-end fish, then Fish Finery could easily become a new favorite. There’s no frozen fish whatsoever, which is a forerunning hallmark of the exemplary quality to expect. 

Where To Buy The Best Frozen Seafood Online

Fresh frozen fish and seafood involves the rapid freezing of catch shortly after it’s harvested which prevents the formation of large ice crystals that damage the texture and flavor. This method is highly efficient and helps preserve the seafood’s quality, resulting in the best frozen fish possible which can often be superior to fish that’s been standing on ice for long.

Wild Fork Foods

Regions ServedLocal Pickup In | Nationwide Shipping Available
DeliveryComprehensive On-Site Tracking Of All Orders
SmellCleanly Packed With Low To No Odor Detectable
FlavorPremium Handling & Quality Results In Fresh, Clean Flavor
Customer ServiceHighly Responsive, Attentive, Friendly Customer Service Via Phone, Website, Live Chat And Email 
AffordabilityModerate
ShippingFree Shipping For WF Unlimited Members Offered On $35+ Orders ($29 Annual Membership)National shipping (Two-day Ground or Next Day Air): $29.95 – $99.95
Seafood RangeWild Halibut, Wild Gulf White Shrimp, Barramundi, Wild Sockeye Salmon, Wild Guinean Sole, Easy Peel Shrimp, Wild Stone Crab, Turbot, Wild Octopus, Carabineros Scarlet Shrimp, Smoked Salmon, Wild King Salmon, Wild Goldband Snapper, Southern Hake, Wild Wahoo, Panapesca Blue Mussels, Wild Snapper, Ahi Tuna, Key West Pink Shrimp, Petite Sea Scallops, Spiny Lobster, North Atlantic Lobster, Hard Shell Clams, Peruvian Bay Scallops, Spanish Razor Clams, Stone Crab, Sea Scallops, Langoustines, Crawfish, White Shrimp, Texas Gulf Brown Shrimp, Stick Style Surimi (Imitation Crab), Wild Calamari, Rockefeller Oysters, Spanish Coquina Clams, Galician Mussels, Wild Argentine Red Shrimp, Bay Scallops, Green Shell Mussels, New England Bay Scallops

Embracing a pioneering spirit in the realm of online food retail, Wild Fork Foods has carved out a distinctive niche in the market with its commitment to offering top-tier, blast-frozen products that range from meat and seafood to produce and beyond. By employing the innovative technology of ultra-low temperature blast freezing, the brand guarantees the encapsulation of essential nutrients and robust flavors, thereby ensuring that their extensive array of offerings remains tantalizingly close to their fresh counterparts. The company champions the technique of blast freezing, which operates at a speed ten times quicker than conventional flash-freezing, thereby minimizing crystallization and ensuring that seafood, meat, and other products are preserved at a brisk -40°F, curbing the depletion of both nutrition and taste over time.

Since inaugurating its first storefront in Coral Gables, Florida, in 1995, Wild Fork Foods has experienced a steadfast expansion across the United States, with its corporate epicenter currently anchored in Doral, Florida. A haven for aficionados of high-quality meat and seafood, Wild Fork Foods presents an impressive portfolio of over 700 individual products, effortlessly eclipsing the offerings of many rival specialty food retailers. This encompasses not only premier beef, poultry, pork, and seafood but also extends to an array of health-conscious, ethically sourced exotic meats, a spectrum of plant-based proteins, and a diverse selection of spices and sauces. For an  indepth look at what to expect from one of the best retailers online, be sure to check out our dedicated review of Wild Fork Foods.

Catalina Offshore Products

Regions ServedDiscounted Shipping Within California | Nationwide Shipping Available
DeliveryNext Day Delivery With FedEx Tracking
SmellVacuum Sealing – Low To No Odor
FlavorRelatively Fresh And Clean
Customer ServiceDedicated Support Via Email, Fax, Telephone & Social Media
AffordabilityHigh
ShippingWithin California – Free Shipping On Orders Of $200+All Other US Orders – Free Shipping On Orders Of $300+$15 Flat Rate Shipping Charge For Southern California (Below Threshold)$25 Flat Rate Shipping Charge For Northern California (Below Threshold)$50 Flat Rate Shipping Charge For Rest Of USA (Below Threshold)
Seafood RangeAlaskan Halibut, Black Cod (Sablefish), Chilean Sea Bass, Grouper, Halibut (Flounder), Mahi Mahi, Opah, Snapper, Wahoo (Ono), White Seabass, Wild Pacific Sushi Grade Ahi (Maguro) Tuna, Wild Pacific Northwest Sashimi Grade Albacore (Shiro Maguro) Tuna, Southern California Wild Caught Sushi Grade Albacore (Shiro Maguro) Tuna, Wild Pacific Sushi Grade Bluefin (Akami Maguro) Tuna, Pacific Sashimi Grade Bluefin Toro Tuna, Farmed Sashimi Grade Canadian Salmon (Sake), Sushi Grade Escolar, Faroe Islands Sashimi Grade Salmon (Sake), Farmed Sashimi Grade Kanpachi, Farmed Sashimi Grade Japanese Yellowtail, Farmed Mt. Cook SAIKOU Sashimi Grade Salmon (Sake), Farmed Norwegian Sashimi Grade Salmon, Wild Sashimi Grade Yellowfin Saku (Akami/Maguro) Ahi Tuna, Sushi Grade Sea Scallops, Wild Mexican Shrimp, Sashimi Grade Abalone (Awabi), Arctic Surf Clams (Hokkigai), Butterfly Shrimp, California Spiny Lobster, Cuttlefish (Mono Ika), Imitation Crab Meat (Kani Kama), Soft Shell Crabs (Primes), Squid (Calamari), Tempura Shrimp, Wild Mexican Shrimp, Ikura Salmon Roe Caviar, Masago Capelin Roe Caviar, Tobiko Black Caviar (Flying Fish Roe), Tobiko Green Wasabi Caviar, Tobiko Red Caviar, Tobiko Yuzu-Citrus Caviar, California Gold Uni, California Premium Uni, Sea Urchin Vana (C-Grade Uni)

San Diego-based Catalina Offshore Products stocks high-quality frozen seafood at reasonable prices. Most of the fish sold is flash-frozen by means of a process referred to as ‘Proton Freezing.’ This method of rapid electromagnetic refrigeration creates the smallest ice crystals possible, thereby protecting the flavor and texture of the meat. While the company’s range carries several high-end options like sushi-grade salmon of various varieties and premium Californian uni, it’s the delicacy Opah that draws many customers in. Opah, also known as moonfish, is a true gem of the ocean and the seafood Catalina has become famous for. This magnificent fish boasts a sweet, rich, and buttery flavor that’s often likened to a cross between tuna and swordfish. 

Catalina Offshore Products has held its esteemed reputation as the go-to destination in the region for seafood enthusiasts for an impressive span of over four decades. Exceptional customer service is to be expected. In the rare instance that you might find any aspect of their quality lacking, they offer a hassle-free return policy, a testament to their unwavering commitment to excellence. However, such instances are indeed a rarity because Catalina Offshore consistently delivers nothing short of the finest seafood across the board. Their dedication to providing top-notch quality makes them a standout choice for seafood aficionados seeking the very best no matter where in the US they may be. 

Riviera Seafood Club

Regions ServedLocal Pickup Available In Los Angeles| Discounted Shipping In Southern California | Nationwide Shipping Available
DeliveryReal-Time Tracking Of Parcel Delivery
SmellVery Low Odor Despite Super Freezing
FlavorFresh Clean Flavor
Customer ServiceReliable Telephonic And Online Support Offered
AffordabilityLow
ShippingFree Shipping Within Continental USA For All Orders Of $175+Southern California Shipments Expedited Free Delivery On Orders Of $125+
Seafood RangeBluefin Tuna Akami, Chutoro & Otoro, Calvisius Oscietra Classic Caviar, Calvisius Siberian Caviar, Gindara Sablefish, Baja Mexico Halibut, Hokkaido Japanese Scallops, La Paz Kampachi Filet, Kampachi Collars (Kama), Atlantic Salmon Collars, Ora King Salmon Filet, Ora King Salmon Collars, Kabayaki Unagi, Wild-Caught Uni, Wild-Caught Blue Shrimp, Blue Shrimp Burgers, Regal New Zealand King Salmon, Pacific Coast Swordfish

Riviera Seafood Club boasts an impressive range of premier seafood that’s available either fresh or super frozen. The Los Angeles-based seafood stockist is the ideal place to shop for high-end fish, gourmet pantry goods, and sushi components. It’s sushi-grade fish and seafood delivery at its best, but expect to pay pretty high for most cuts. Restaurants and chefs in Southern California can take advantage of wholesale pricing by inquiry. Yes, Riviera’s seafood is that good. Fortunately, shipping is free on orders of $175 or above, and customers can always expect speedy delivery. Deliveries are fulfilled using Next Day Air, and orders are typically shipped the day after ordering, order time dependent. 

The packaging used ensures total insulation without a need for freezing, and super-frozen goods defrost without any noticeable odor or off-putting flavor – the freshness remains impeccable. While the selection itself and overall quality are among the highest available across all stockists, demand is high, which means that many products run out fast. Keen customers can also take advantage of the generous weekly specials that update according to in-season availability and/or exciting new additions to the range. Be on the lookout for family pack discounts, too, and if you plan to shop often, don’t miss the rewards program.  

Meat ‘N Bone

Regions ServedLocal Delivery In Miami-Dade, Broward & Palm Beach | 48 Hour Delivery In Florida | Nationwide Shipping Available
Delivery24-Hour Nationwide Delivery Average With Up To 4 Days Shipping Time
SmellMinimally Low To No Fishy Odor
FlavorCareful Handling And High Quality Standards Ensure Prime Freshness And Flavor
Customer ServiceAttentive, Friendly Support Via Live Chat, Social Media, Email & Telephone
AffordabilityHigh
ShippingFree Delivery Of Goods When Scheduled Ahead Of Time
Seafood RangeOra King Salmon, Turkish Mediterranean Branzino, Sushi-Grade Hamachi, Caribbean AAA Grade Yellowfin Tuna, Wild African Tiger Prawns, Boston U8 Scallops, Wild Rocky Mountains Freshwater Trout, Wild Caribbean Grouper, Costa Rican Sashimi Grade Tuna Saku, Wild Caribbean Red Snapper, Wild Florida Keys Hook Caught YellowTail Snapper, Pacific Mahi Mahi, Chilean Sea Bass, Chilean Atlantic Salmon, Mexican Wild Hook Caught Hog Snapper, Spanish Sole, Spanish Octopus, Maine Lobster, Wild Caribbean Lobster, Wild Australian Lobster, Vietnamese Whole Clams, Californian Greenlip Abalone, Wild Key West Pink Shrimp, Wild Equatorial Shrimp, Kristal Caviar, Oscietra Gold Caviar (Osstra), Sterling Sturgeon Caviar, South African Whole Calamari, Indonesian Yellowfin Tuna, Chu-Toro Bluefin Tuna, O-Toro Bluefin Tuna, Tuna Tataki AAA Tuna, Indonesian Blue Swimming Crab, Florida Stone Crab, Swordfish, Wild Monster African Tiger Prawns, Santa Barbara Uni, Wild Caught Korean Escolar Saku, Columbian Rainbow Trout, Boston Uni

Navigating the competitive seas of online meat and seafood retail, Meat N’ Bone emerges as a beacon of exceptional quality and robust service, often being acclaimed for surpassing the caliber found in conventional stores and eateries. The brainchild of trio Luis Mata, Germann Vollbracht, and Gabriel Llaurado, this virtual butcher shop was brought into existence with a singular vision: to deliver more than 400 premium, meticulously curated selections of meat, seafood, and poultry right to consumers’ doorsteps. While beef remains a focal point in their offerings, their assortment splendidly cascades into an ocean of other choices, with their seafood selections maintaining the company’s fresh, high-quality standard held throughout the range.

Their precise delivery methods ensure the integrity of their product, utilizing vacuum-sealed, airtight, food-safe bags and cooler bags filled with dry ice to preserve every ounce of quality during transit. The ethos of Meat N’ Bone revolves intricately around the provision of superior-grade meats, handpicked by seasoned experts, to carve out a niche of excellence in the digital space. The brand, while operating exclusively online, provides an added layer of convenience with its express delivery options — free same-day and two-hour delivery in specific Florida locales, including Miami-Dade and parts of Palm Beach and Broward. Those residing beyond these regions aren’t left stranded, as the company extends its reach nationally via UPS, albeit with a reasonable shipping fee. For more detailed information concerning this excellent supplier, don’t miss our comprehensive Meat N’ Bone review

Whidbey Island Seafood Company

Regions ServedFree Shipping Within Washington State | Discounted Shipping Oregon | Nationwide Shipping Available
DeliveryUPS Tracking
SmellLow Odor Only Detectable In Outer Packaging
FlavorOcean Fresh Flavor With High Handling Standards
Customer ServiceReliable Support Via On-Site Live Chat, Contact Form Or Phone
AffordabilityLow
ShippingFree Shipping On Orders Of $50+ Within Washington State and OregonMinimum Order Of $100 For Nationwide Shipping @ FedEx RatesFree Nationwide Shipping For Orders Of $250+
Seafood RangeAlaskan King Salmon, Alaskan Coho Salmon, Alaskan Sockeye Salmon, Alaskan Black Cod, Alaskan White King Salmon, Alaskan Black Cod (Sablefish), Alaskan Lingcod, Alaskan Bairdi Crab, Alaskan Dungeness Crab, Alaskan Red King Crab, Alaskan Snow Crab (Opilio), Pacific Halibut, Alaskan Spot Prawns, Alaskan Sidestripe Shrimp, Canadian Sashimi Grade Spot Prawns, Alaskan Shortraker Rockfish, Atlantic Sea Scallops, Sashimi Grade Pacific Albacore Tuna

The first thing prospective customers will notice is the high-end pricing of Whidbey Island Seafood Company, but one has to remember that the entire range is wild-caught. At almost double the cost per pound of King Salmon sold by the most affordable of stockists like Amazon Fresh, this select seafood certainly has a lot to live up to. Fortunately, the company guarantees some of the highest quality flash-frozen fish and shellfish around by sticking to a limited number of trusted harvesters, each of which specializes in a finite range of sustainably sourced marine life from specific locations in the sea. As a result, customers can expect to find exceptionally high-quality wild-caught Alaskan salmon and a range of other popular fish like sashimi-grade tuna and halibut that are of equal caliber. Smoked varieties of most fish are also offered.

Another upside to shopping here is how low-mercury cuts from younger fish, like loin cuts from  Pacific Albacore Tuna, are on offer – a definite upside for those looking for the healthiest fish possible. Every item sold is flash frozen on board as opposed to being kept on ice. Another reason that customers can rely on Whitbey’s freshness is the way that goods are packaged. Every order is kept cool with ten pounds of dry ice pellets sealed in plastic and wrapped in a thermal wrap. Washington residents have every reason to take advantage of the low Shipping and try out the Whidbey Island Seafood Company’s wares, while all others are strongly urged to give them a try. 

Sea To Table

Regions ServedNationwide Shipping Available (Ships From Virginia, Washington, Nebraska)
DeliveryFedEx, UPS, ONTRAC or GLS-US Shipping With Delivery Within 1 to 3 Days
SmellLow Odor With Fishiness Only Detectable In Packaging
FlavorGood Handling Results In Clean Fish And Reasonably Fresh Flavor
Customer ServiceTrustworthy Online & Telephonic Support
AffordabilityHigh
ShippingFree Shipping On Orders Of $99+
Seafood RangeWild Gulf Shrimp, Wild King Salmon, Alaskan Sockeye Salmon, Northwest Pacific Halibut, Alaskan Coho Salmon, Northwest Pacific Cod, Gulf of Maine Redfish, Pacific Black Cod, Northwest Petrale Sole, Sushi-Grade Atlantic Albacore Tuna

The home seafood delivery service Sea to Table specializes in flash-frozen sustainable wild-caught fish and shellfish. Both prebuilt subscription boxes offering discounted rates on bundles and individual purchases of fish fillets are available. Expect a higher-than-average cost across the board. Fillets are, on average, slightly smaller than at competing retailers, but they’re perfectly trimmed and handled with extreme care. The fish and all seafood are vacuum-sealed in plastic, flash-frozen, and wrapped in butcher paper. They are then packed with eco-friendly insulation and plenty of dry ice to ensure they stay frozen while on their way to your door. 

A full satisfaction guarantee is offered, which promises to replace unsatisfactory orders within thirty days. Between the premium quality of fish, low Shipping, and the variety spanning seafood sourced from coastal towns stretching from Maine along the Gulf Coast and then up to Alaska, Sea to Table is an impressive stockist that comes highly recommended. Those who opt for a subscription box receive a scaling discount of between 3.5% and 6.5%, depending on the delivery schedule. 

Rastelli’s

Regions ServedNationwide Shipping Available (Continental US Only)
DeliveryShipping Within 5 Business Days – UPS Tracking
SmellLow To No Odor
FlavorFresh Flavorful, Clean Seafood
Customer ServiceDiligent Telephonic & Email Support
AffordabilityLow
ShippingFree Shipping On Orders Of $200+$10 Shipping Fee For Orders Between $100-199$25 Shipping Free For Orders Under $100
Seafood RangeFaroe Island Salmon, Wild Swordfish, Wild Icelandic Cod, Wild Sockeye Salmon, Wild Halibut, Faroe Island Cedar Plank Salmon, Wild Sea Scallops, Maine Lobster, Gulf Shrimp, Wild Black Cod (Sablefish), Wild Chilean Sea Bass, Wild Atlantic Flounder, Wild Mahi Mahi

Rastelli’s is a New Jersey-based meat and seafood stockist renowned for its high-value subscription packages. All frozen food from Rastelli’s is frozen at prime freshness, which gives them a 12-month shelf-life when kept in the freezer. The seafood selection is somewhat limited compared to some stockists, but the overall diversity of the range is fantastic. It’s a great place to shop when you’re looking to order antibiotic & hormone-free meat, poultry, and fish together. With meat and seafood sourced from leading suppliers across the US and the Faroe Islands, the quality from this QVC-featured store is vastly superior to most competing frozen food retailers. 

Rastelli’s offers a range of subscription boxes tailored to meat enthusiasts that are far more affordable than individual purchases. The family-owned company is steadfast in its commitment to providing unparalleled seafood. As a store that’s been trusted for over 40 years, Rastelli’s is well worth a try if you’re in the market for both frozen fish and gourmet grilling options like steaks and sausages. It’s farm-to-table meat at its best, with a limited but high-end range of some of the best seafood around. Their products are sourced from sustainable and responsible fisheries, and everything arrives as fresh as it gets. Overall, if you’re a seafood lover looking for high-quality, sustainable products, Rastelli’s is definitely worth checking out.

Kolikof Caviar & Gourmet

Regions ServedFree Local Pickup In Santa Monica | Free Local Delivery In Los Angeles Nationwide Shipping Available
DeliveryFree Local Pickup In Santa Monica | | FedEx Tracking On Overnight / 2-3 Day
SmellNo To Minimally Low Fishy Odor
FlavorSupremely Clean, Well Handled Fish With Ocean Fresh Flavor
Customer ServiceResponsive Live Chat & Friendly Telephonic Support
AffordabilityModerate
ShippingFree Shipping In Los Angeles$32 FedEx Overnight$25 2-3 Day FedEx
Seafood RangeAlaskan King Crab, Alaskan Salmon Roe, Chilean Sea Bass, Dover Sole, Dungeness Crab, European Blue Lobster, European Turbot, Faroe Island Salmon, Giant Black Tiger Shrimp U12, Red King Crab, Ipswich Clams, Langoustine, Maine Lobster, Maine Sea Scallops, New Caledonian Salt Prawns (French Blue Prawns), Sashimi Grade Balik Royal Salmon, Halibut, Snow Crab, South African Lobster, Southern Australian Lobster, Spanish Octopus, Spanish Red Carabineros Prawns, Stone Crabs, Trisan Lobster, U15 Shrimp, Wild Alaskan Halibut, Wild European Branzino

For frozen salmon and other high-end fish and seafood that’s sure to drive up a craving in even those adverse to fishy flavors, Kolikof Caviar & Gourmet is a Santa Monica-based stockist that you can’t go wrong with. The quality of the gourmet-class fish and seafood products is among the highest you’ll find and of high enough caliber to satisfy the needs of Michelin-star chefs. Fillets of fish arrived vacuum-sealed and flash-frozen. Prospective customers can expect to pay a hefty premium, but for discerning cooks, splashing out for this type of freshness in the lure of being frozen will be money well spent. 

Those who can’t bring themselves to opt into a lesser quality after sampling Kolikof’s amazing seafood will find slightly better value than individual purchases from the company’s subscription boxes. Subscriptions for Faroe Island salmon and Wild Alaskan halibut are available delivering weekly. There’s also a half-half box for those who prefer variety. There’s a massive variety of gourmet food sold over and above frozen fish, smoked fish, and shellfish. If it’s high-end, you’ll find it at Kolikof Caviar & Gourmet. It’s the type of place you’ll find everything from edible gold to Australian and Japanese Wagyu to duck, truffles, saffron, exotic cheeses, and some of the best caviar you’ll find in the country. Customers are truly spoiled for choice.

Sizzle Fish

Regions ServedNationwide Shipping Available
DeliveryExpress Shipping (1 to 3 Days) – FedEX/UPS Tracking
SmellLow Odor On Fish, Infrequent Moderate Fishy Smell Within Packaging
FlavorReasonable Handling, Mainly Fresh, Relatively Clean Flavor
Customer ServiceAttentive Customer Service Via Phone, Social Media Or Email
AffordabilityHigh
ShippingFree Shipping On Orders Of $100+
Seafood RangeWild Alaskan King Salmon, Wild Alaskan Halibut, Wild Alaskan Sockeye Salmon, Wild Chilean Sea Bass, Wild Sea Scallops, Wild Gulf Shrimp, Wild Atlantic Cod, Yellowfin Tuna (Ahi), Atlantic Salmon, Maryland Crabs, Wild Atlantic Haddock, Chesapeake Soft Shell Crabs, Sablefish (Black Cod), Rainbow Trout, Maine Lobster, Wild Walleye, Wild Alaskan Coho Salmon, Wild Caught Colossal Shrimp, Catfish, Calamari, Wild Pacific Mahi-Mahi, American Red Snapper, Wild Red Grouper, Carolina Shrimp, Copper River King Salmon, Alaskan Snow Crab, Cedar Key Clams, Wild Atlantic Rockfish, Wild Alaskan King Crab, Black Sea Bass, Ivory King Salmon, Alaskan Weathervane Scallops, Dungeness Crab


The Ayden, North Carolina based seafood delivery service Sizzlefish has gained a reputation for its premium-quality seafood offerings. It boasts an impressive variety of deep-sea fish and shellfish. All seafood is sourced from reputable fisheries, and you can taste the difference in the freshness and flavor of their products. The fillets are expertly trimmed and vacuum-sealed to lock in freshness while deliveries arrive packed in a reusable insulated container with dry ice, ensuring that fishy odors are minimal to non-existent. As flash-frozen products, those not happy with the quality have a full week to request a replacement. 

Sizzlefish offers a freshness guarantee, assuring customers that their seafood will arrive fresh or their money back. This commitment to quality is a testament to their confidence in their products. Customers will find that most, if not all, the bones are removed from fillets. Their website is user-friendly, making the ordering process straightforward. You can choose from curated selections or build your own box, customizing your order to your liking. With an ultra-low threshold for free nationwide shipping and a reasonably priced range, customers in the market for flash-frozen fish have every reason to try Sizzlefish. 

Domestic Seafood

Regions ServedFree Nationwide Shipping (Conditions Apply)
DeliveryFedEx, UPS, or USPS Tracking – Next Day Shipping Available Before 12PM Otherwise 2 Day Delivery
SmellMild To Low Fishiness
FlavorGood Flavor With Mild Fishiness
Customer ServiceImmediate Customer Support Via Email & Telephone With Non-Edible Refunds Only
AffordabilityModerate
ShippingFree Delivery On All Orders
Seafood RangeMaine Lobster, Halibut, Massachusetts Domestic Scallops, Premium White Shrimp, Chilean Sea Bass, Rhode Island Calamari, Blue Crab, Grouper, Georgia White Shrimp, Yellowfin Tuna, Swordfish, Siberian Beluga Caviar, Mussels, Spanish Octopus, Classic American Caviar, Classic Osetra Caviar, Hackleback Roe, Paddlefish Roe, Imperial American Caviar, Golden Osetra Caviar, Golden Sterlet Caviar, Kaluga Beluga Caviar, Salmon Roe, Sevruga Caviar, Spanish Crawfish

The Miami-based retailer Domestic Seafood stands firmly behind flashing freezing seafood, as can be seen by the brand’s ongoing marketing of the #FreshlyFrozen hashtag. All boats supplying the company freeze their catch immediately after harvest, not a moment later, producing frozen quality that’s far ahead of most of the competition. In addition to well-handled, high-quality frozen seafood, beef, lamb, pork, chicken, veal, caviar, and a range of gourmet sausages are also available. Essentially, the company is stocked by five subsidiaries, namely American Butcher, Inland Seafood, Woodsmoke Provisions (smoked seafood), Inland Market (grocery items), and Inland lobster.

The overwhelming popularity of Domestic Seafood means that stocks run out fast, so keen customers are advised to keep a frequent eye on their favorite products. One would think that it is largely due to the free delivery policy, but the quality is actually among the best you’ll find among frozen seafood markets online. An “Off The Hook” Section updates customers with the freshest FleshlyFrozen catches as they come in. If you’re in the market for classic seafood that’s capable of being stored for extended periods while defrosting to a superior quality thanks to great handling, this is a top place to shop. 

Never Frozen Shellfish

The following retailers supply the freshest, tastiest oysters, mussels, geoduck, clams, and other shellfish delicacies online. Here are the best places to buy never-frozen shellfish in the USA, ensuring ocean-fresh goodness in good time with every order. 

Hama Hama Oysters

Regions ServedDiscounted Shipping In Washington and Oregon | Nationwide Shipping Available (Continental USA Only)
DeliveryFedEx Tracking Of 2-Day Deliveries Between 4:30 PM and 8:00 PM
SmellUltra-Fresh, No Odor
FlavorExceptional Freshness & Clean Flavor
Customer ServiceReliable Customer Support Via Email
AffordabilityModerate
ShippingFree Shipping On Orders Of 12 Dozen Oysters/Clams Or MoreWashington and Oregon – $10Idaho and California – $40Other states – $50Alaska – $65
Seafood RangeBlue Pool Oysters, Hama Hama Oysters, Manila Clams, Grillers, Purple Savory Clams, Shucked Oysters, Mussels, Canned Smoked Oysters

The Hama Hama Oyster Company, nestled on Washington’s scenic Olympic Peninsula, is a venerable family-operated shellfish farm currently stewarded by the sixth generation. Renowned for cultivating exquisite oysters that eloquently express the clean, crisp flavors of the undisturbed waters of one of Washington State’s shortest and coldest rivers, the company seamlessly merges traditional, low-impact farming methods with a palpable passion for delivering world-class oysters. The Hama Hama oysters from Washington State present a delightful culinary experience distinctively flavored by the Pacific Northwest. 

Celebrated for their bold, crisp character and a pleasing brininess balanced with a subtle minerality, these oysters are recognized not just for their flavor but also for their sturdy shells, reflecting a life in the brisk, clean currents of their native river delta. Appreciated for their versatility, Hama Hama oysters shine, whether served on the half shell, grilled or in a rich chowder, providing a full yet not overpowering mix of salt and green flavors. They stand out for their remarkable shuck-ability and, with their mildly briny aftertaste and strong shells, encapsulate a pure, vibrant expression of the Pacific Northwest’s bivalve offerings. Ordering from the Hama Hama Oyster Company presents affordable oysters of the highest quality packed in insulated boxes with frozen gel ice, ensuring freshness without freezing on every item.

Taylor Shellfish Farms

Regions ServedNationwide Shipping Offered | Local Pickup In Bellingham, WA · Seattle, WA · Portland, Bellevue, WA, Shelton, WA
DeliveryFedEx, UPS or USPS Tracking On Next Day Shipping
SmellLow To No Fishy Odor
FlavorExcellent Ocean Fresh Flavor
Customer ServiceFriendly Support Via Live Chat, Email, Social Media & Phone
AffordabilityModerate
ShippingFree Express Shipping On All Orders Of $250+Free Express Shipping On All Non-Perishable Orders of $75+$10 Shipping Within Western Washington$40 Shipping Anywhere Else In The US
Seafood RangePacific Griller Oysters, Sumo Kumo Oysters, Fanny Bay Sunseeker Oysters, Totten Inlet Virginica Oysters, Fat Bastard Oysters, Shigoku Oysters, Olympia Oysters, Kumamoto Oysters, Frozen Top Off Oysters, Pacific Petite Oysters, Shucked Oyster Meat, Ekone Scallops, Totten Inlet Mussels, Manila Clams, Geoduck, Wild Pacific Razor Clams, Canned Octopus, Canned Abalone, Canned Smoked Albacore, Canned Smoked Oysters, Canned Smoked Mussels, Canned Smoked Coho Salmon

Taylor Shellfish Farms keeps both fresh and frozen shellfish, although it’s the live oysters, clams, mussels, and geoduck that are the forerunning favorites from the company’s range. It’s a 5th generation family-run company that’s been around since 1890 and is clearly one of the best the region (or country, for that matter) has to offer. Shellfish making a part of the range are sourced from Fanny Bay Oysters, a top distributor situated in British Columbia. While the entire range exhibits superior quality to almost all competing shellfish, it’s the oysters and, in particular, the Shigoku oyster that customers rave about. Shigoku oysters are famous for their distinctive tidal-tumbled shape and clean, crisp flavor profile.

Cultivated meticulously with a technique that mimics the natural motion of tides, each oyster boasts a deep, petite cup that cradles a delicate morsel, presenting an elegant balance of sweet and briny notes to the palate. 

The texture is a harmonious blend of plumpness and a refreshing oceanic crispness, culminating in a slightly nutty finish that lingers delightfully, and there’s no better place to shop for this delicacy. Taylor Shellfish Farms has brick-and-mortar marketplaces in Seattle, Shelton, and Samish Bay, so be sure to pop to sample their amazing shellfish firsthand. Otherwise, the overnight shipping service can be relied on for the freshest seafood around, no matter where you may be situated. 

Frequently Asked Questions – Where To Buy The Best Seafood Online

Have you been left wondering anything concerning where to buy the best seafood online or the nuances of purchasing from a fish market in general? We may have the answers you’re looking for waiting here. 

How Long Can I Leave Fish In The Refrigerator?

The shelf life of fish in a refrigerator is influenced by factors such as fish type and initial freshness. Generally, fatty fish like salmon and mackerel can be safely stored for 2 to 3 days, while lean fish like cod or sole last about 1 to 2 days. Whole fish tend to stay fresher longer than fillets or steaks. To maintain freshness, refrigerate fish at or below 40°F using airtight containers or resealable bags. Always rely on your senses to detect signs of spoilage, such as unusual odors or changes in texture. For extended storage, consider freezing fish, where it can remain in good condition for several months.

Which Types Of Seafood Require Freezing?

Freezing seafood is influenced by factors like the type of fish, its initial freshness, and its intended use. Fatty fish such as salmon and mackerel, which are prone to quicker spoilage, greatly benefit from freezing. You can freeze them for about 2 to 3 months while maintaining quality. Lean fish like cod or sole have a longer refrigerator shelf life, but freezing extends it to around 6 months, provided it’s well-packaged to prevent freezer burn. Shellfish like shrimp, lobster, and crab freeze well and maintain their quality for 3 to 6 months. However, sashimi-grade fish, prized for freshness, is best consumed immediately and shouldn’t be frozen unless you have specific culinary plans that require it. Always use airtight containers or freezer bags for optimal freezing results.

What Is The Difference Between Fresh And Frozen Fish And Seafood?

Diving into the fresh vs. frozen seafood discourse, it’s pivotal to recognize the distinct culinary and scientific aspects each category brings to the table. Fresh seafood, typically moving directly from harvest to consumer, retains its integral cellular structure and natural aromatic compounds, providing a pristine, unaltered flavor and texture that is often revered in raw or gently cooked applications. The immediacy of fresh fish and seafood not only assures a peek into the ingredient’s inherent quality but also subtly challenges chefs to articulate these nuanced flavors and textures vividly on the plate.

Conversely, frozen seafood, especially when flash-frozen, ensures the preservation of cellular integrity while simultaneously halting microbial activity, essentially enshrining the ingredient in a post-harvest state. While certain aromatic volatiles might be muted, the accessibility, sustainability, and global reach offered by frozen seafood cannot be understated, empowering chefs with a diversified ingredient arsenal. Thus, the choice between fresh and frozen becomes less of a quality dichotomy and more of a strategic culinary decision, harmonizing ingredient integrity with the intended dining experience.

Which Fish Are The Most Sustainable?

Some of the most sustainable fish options include wild-caught Alaskan salmon, which is carefully managed to prevent overfishing. US-farmed rainbow trout is another eco-friendly choice, as it’s raised in closed systems that minimize environmental impact. Pacific sardines are abundant and reproduce quickly, making them a sustainable option. Additionally, US-caught Pacific albacore tuna, farmed catfish and Dungeness crab are generally considered sustainable choices. To make eco-conscious decisions, look for certifications like the Marine Stewardship Council (MSC) label, which indicates that the fish was sourced responsibly.

How To Defrost Fish

Say goodbye to the old “refrigerator thawing” routine with our go-to method: the cold water bath. Simply submerge your sealed seafood package in cold water, changing it every 30 minutes, and let it thaw for approximately 1 hour per pound. 


Recent Recipes