Best Grocery Store Olive Oils
Important Note: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Content, pricing, offers and availability are subject to change at any time - more info.
Tired of olive oil confusion when shopping for an affordable variety? Ditch the marketing hype, and let’s talk real. We’ve scoured supermarket shelves and e-grocers to find the hidden gems: mid-priced olive oils that don’t compromise on purity or flavor. All the best grocery store olive oils are reviewed, and each is guaranteed to be pure and packed with natural flavor. These ever-popular products are totally unadulterated by other oils and/or additives. They can be relied on to elevate your dishes from good to great, one drizzle at a time. Dive into our no-nonsense guide and discover the perfect pantry staples for everyday drizzling, dipping, and dressing – your taste buds (and wallet) will thank you.
Key Takeaways
- Although every product reviewed here is pure and free from any form of adulterants or blending with other types of oil, the number one factor to confirm before buying any grocery store olive oil is that it contains olive oil alone and nothing else.
- When one opts to buy a large volume of olive oil, such as a gallon or a gallon and a half tin, the price comes down so much that brands that would often be out of reach in regular quantities equal the cost of mid-range olive oil not bought in bulk.
- Unless you’re using a refined olive oil or a blend of refined and unrefined, avoid frying at high temperatures, as you’ll destroy the flavor and aromatic compounds within seconds. Moderate heat sauteing is ideal (no higher than a few degrees under the smoke point of 405°F for EVOO) and using it as a finishing oil exclusively will reward one with the fullest possible flavor.
- Olive oil is a healthy option rich in monounsaturated fats and antioxidants, but the mid-range grocery store oils priced at the lower end of the scale are very low in phenolic compounds. For higher, healthier concentrations of oleuropein, hydroxytyrosol, and their derivatives which are responsible for the spiciness, flavor, aroma and health benefits, you’ll have to look towards high phenolic & high hydroxytyrosol olive oil brands which we have a comprehensive overview of waiting.
- Key Takeaways
- Top 10 Best Grocery Store Olive Oils
- Graza “Sizzle” Extra Virgin Olive Oil
- 100% California Extra Virgin Olive Oil Bag In A Box
- AmazonFresh Mediterranean Blend
- Colavita Olive Oil Tin, Large
- 365 by Whole Foods Market Extra Virgin Mediterranean Olive Oil
- Kirkland Signature Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil
- Bertolli Olive Oil, Extra Virgin Rich
- ZOE Extra Virgin Olive
- Iliada Extra Virgin Olive Oil
- Pompeian Extra Virgin Olive Oil
- Notable Mentions – Good Grocery Olive Oils
- Top 5 Grocery Store Olive Oil Sprays
- California Olive Ranch, 100% California Extra Virgin Olive Oil Spray
- Bertolli 100% Extra Virgin Olive Oil Spray
- Pompeian USDA Certified Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil Non-Stick Cooking Spray
- Mantova Organic Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil Spray
- 365 by Whole Foods Market, Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil Spray
- Frequently Asked Questions – Best Grocery Store Olive Oils
Top 10 Best Grocery Store Olive Oils
As one will notice, the vast majority of brands offer at least two different varieties of olive oil, namely extra virgin and robust. Some also have light olive oil available for those who are looking for a very neutral taste. Only each brand’s most popular type is reviewed, with alternate options listed for those who prefer a different flavor profile. Here are the very best grocery store olive oils at affordable prices.
Graza “Sizzle” Extra Virgin Olive Oil
| Origin | Jaen, Spain |
| Flavor | Boasting A Robust Yet Mellow Character, Infused With Zesty Notes, And Exhibiting Impeccable Balance |
| Aroma | Highly Aromatic, Radiating Freshness That Mirrors Its Rich But Mild Flavor Profile |
| Sizes | 25.336 Fluid Ounces (750Ml) |
| Affordability | Low |
| Other Varieties | Graza “Drizzle” Extra Virgin Olive Oil |
Graza “Sizzle” Extra Virgin Olive Oil has become a notable choice in the culinary realm, capturing attention for its top-tier quality, versatility, robust flavor, and premiere, pioneering packaging. It is hard to find olive oil that has a single farm origin like Graza at a reasonable price, and the balance and flavor itself are out of this world. If Graza Sizzle is a little too zesty, after all, it’s intended for frying and finishing, give Graza Drizzle a try – they’re two of the best tasting grocery store olive oils you’ll ever sample. They’re a little higher priced than most mid-range grocery store oils, but only by a few cents per ounce. The flavor, quality, and durable ever-practical squeeze-bottle design, however, make it worth its weight in gold. Essentially, Graza’s Sizzle is premiere olive oil made from mid-harvest olives that’s equal to that used as a finishing oil in high-end restaurants at a rock bottom price.
Sourced from Jaen, Spain, Graza focuses on the purity of its product, ensuring that every bottle contains 100% extra virgin olive oil derived from carefully picked picual olives renowned for their high oil content and bold, complex flavor. The mature point of harvest ensures Graza has a lingering bite like few other mild oils can compare to. It actually takes no less than thirteen pounds of olives to produce a little over a quarter a gallon of Graza. From the moment that one begins to heat this superbly viscous olive oil, its aroma hints towards the quality. Its mellow but zesty flavor profile with just the right degree of characteristic spiciness instantly identifies it as high-end pure oil to any discerning olive oil fan. Even if you use quite a bit of olive oil in your household or restaurant, Graza still makes for an affordable, hard-to-beat choice.
100% California Extra Virgin Olive Oil Bag In A Box
| Origin | California |
| Flavor | Smooth, Light With Fruity, Herbaceous, Peppery Notes, Well-Rounded Depth, And Superb Complexity |
| Aroma | Soft And Balanced, Displaying Mild Neutrality Accentuated By Subtle Earthy Nuances And A Gentle Peaking Herbaceous Touch |
| Sizes | 68 Fluid Ounces |
| Affordability | Very Low |
| Other Varieties | California Olive Ranch Global Blend Medium Extra Virgin Olive Oil, California Olive Ranch California Collection Olive Oil, California Olive Ranch Reserve Collection: Miller’s Blend Extra Virgin Olive Oil |
California Olive Ranch stands out as a distinguished producer of extra virgin olive oil, and a comprehensive evaluation underscores its excellence. Crafted from freshly pressed Californian olives, this oil captures the essence of quality with a smooth flavor accented by delightful hints of green reminiscent of understated green apple. Its aromatic profile is a symphony of floral, buttery, and fruity notes, elevating the taste of just about anything it’s added to. Bold and bright, it effortlessly transforms simple ingredients into culinary masterpieces thanks to the way that it manages to linger in flavor.
Packaged in a thoughtfully designed recyclable plastic bottle that shields the oil from sunlight, 100% California Olive Ranch ensures not just quality but also environmental responsibility. With a shelf life tied to the harvest date, the oil maintains freshness well and always arrives set to last. It’s not necessarily the cheapest grocery store olive oil but the difference in depth of flavor is most-definitely there and worth every cent. California Olive Ranch has also garnered numerous awards, a testament to its unwavering commitment to quality that we urge all olive oil fans to try out.
AmazonFresh Mediterranean Blend
| Origin | Bottled In Italy, Olives Sourced From Greece, Italy and Spain |
| Flavor | Mild, Earthy, And Herbaceous |
| Aroma | Sharp, Earthy And Bolder Than It’s Flavor |
| Sizes | 16.9 Fluid Ounces, 67.63 Fluid Ounces |
| Affordability | High |
| Other Varieties | Amazon Brand – Happy Belly Olive Oil, Amazon Fresh Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil |
Amazon carries several varieties of high quality olive oil, all packaged in economical green-shaded plastic bottles and all products carry a climate-friendly pledge. Subsidiaries of the brand can be trusted for purity and reasonably good flavor and aromatics. The overwhelming favorite from Amazon’s range arises as the AmazonFresh Mediterranean Blend. It’s far stronger than most affordably priced robust grocery store olive oils, which is a huge plus. Everything from a dense velvety viscosity to a lingering peppery sensation and olive-y aroma when heated reflect just how value-packed Amazon olive oil actually is. Admittedly, high phenolic olive oil does get far stronger, but most budget brands simply can’t compare to this quality.
It’s easy to fall in love with the balance that AmazonFresh Mediterranean Blend presents. It’s the type of olive oil that one can easily end up using for just about everything, especially when you want a prominent olive-basd flavor, and when one considers the affordability, the idea grows even more merit. Amazon’s olive oils are even pure enough for dipping and drizzling, and as such, make the perfect finishing oils. Yet, they can be relied upon for never losing too much of their flavor through cooking either. If you use olive oil daily and want tasty oil that doesn’t break the bank, consider AmazonFresh Mediterranean Blend or Amazon Brand (previously Happy Belly) for something lighter.
Colavita Olive Oil Tin, Large
| Origin | Italy (Processed, Bottled & Sourced) |
| Flavor | Smooth, Complex, Light And Bright |
| Aroma | Lightly Floral With Subdued Intensity And Understated Fruity Notes |
| Sizes | 101.4 Fluid Ounces |
| Affordability | Moderate |
| Other Varieties | Colavita Mediterranean Extra Virgin Olive Oil – Large 101.4 Fluid Ounce Tin, Colavita Mediterranean Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Colavita Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil 2Lt (68 Fl Oz) Plastic Jug, Colavita Premium Selection Extra Virgin Olive Oil 68 Fl Oz, Colavita 100% Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil 17 Oz, Colavita Premium Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil, 68 fl. oz. (2 Liters) Jug, Colavita Premium Selection Extra Virgin Olive Oil 68 Fl Oz, Colavita Premium Selection Extra Virgin Olive Oil Glass Bottle 25.5 Fl Oz, Colavita 100% Californian Extra Virgin Olive Oil – 25.5 Fl. Oz, Colavita Extra Virgin Olive Oil in Tin 3L Tin, Colavita Premium Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil Tin, 101.4 Fl. Oz. Tin, Colavita Mediterranean Extra Virgin Olive Oil – Large 101.4 Fl Oz Tin |
Colavita Olive Oil stands out among grocery store options as a popular favorite, offering a premium experience that becomes remarkably affordable when purchased in bulk. While it may be on the pricier side individually, the cost diminishes to a budget-friendly level when buying in larger quantities. Beyond its cost-effectiveness, Colavita impresses with its excellent smoothness, light yet earthy aroma, and a captivatingly complex depth of flavor. If you prefer an olive oil that’s exceptionally light in flavor, Colavita might be your top choice. Its ultra-high smoke point of 428°F, a result of a proprietary blend of high-quality refined and unrefined olive oil, adds to its versatility in cooking.
What makes Colavita even more appealing is its proud processing in the USA, using olives sourced from Turkey. The aggressive pricing coupled with quality that exceeds expectations makes it a reliable choice for all culinary needs, especially the more blended applications. Known for its neutral profile, this olive oil is suitable for virtually every cooking application. However, it’s wise to monitor pricing, as some customers have reported significant cost fluctuations during certain periods. Nevertheless, when the price per ounce drops to around half a dollar or less, Colavita Olive Oil becomes a steal, combining affordability, quality, and versatility in an impressive package.
365 by Whole Foods Market Extra Virgin Mediterranean Olive Oil
| Origin | Undisclosed |
| Flavor | Mild And Neutral With Slight Earthiness And Light Earthy Herby Undertones & Highlights |
| Aroma | Sweet And Earthy With Slight Floral Notes, Close Match To Taste |
| Sizes | 33.8 Fluid Ounces |
| Affordability | High |
| Other Varieties | 365 by Whole Foods Market Greek Extra Virgin Olive Oil, 365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Extra Virgin Mediterranean Olive Oil, 365 by Whole Foods Market Small Batch California Extra Virgin Olive Oil, 365 by Whole Foods Market Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil, 365 by Whole Foods Market Unfiltered Extra Virgin Italian Olive Oil, 365 by Whole Foods Market Unfiltered Extra Virgin California Olive Oil |
365 by Whole Foods Market’s Extra Virgin Mediterranean Olive Oil stands out as a quality and affordable choice for consumers. Cold-processed and meeting the International Olive Council standards, this olive oil variety boasts a fruity aroma and sweetly balanced flavor, suitable for a wide array of culinary applications, from baking to marinades. Packaged in a practical plastic bottle that shields it from light, the oil offers excellent value for its budget-friendly price with superb balance of flavor that’s accurately mirrored by its pleasing, albeit almost non-peppery, aroma. Yet, while prevailingly mild in aroma, the peppery burn of good olive oil is there.
365 by Whole Foods Market has four varieties available. The Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil, certified organic, promises a balanced, fruity taste rich in antioxidants. The Spanish Extra Virgin Olive Oil delivers an authentic, bold flavor with high polyphenol content. The 365 Everyday Value Organic Mediterranean Blend Olive Oil offers a multifaceted taste experience, blending oils from various regions. Finally, the Whole Foods Market Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil, sourced from Italy, provides a smooth and flavorful option packed with healthy monounsaturated fats and antioxidants. Each of these products are mid-range leaders within grocery store olive oils that are likely to be loved by those who appreciate delicate balance.
Kirkland Signature Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil
| Origin: | Multiple Countries In The Mediterranean |
| Flavor | Fruity With Gentle Peppery Whisper, Blending Richness With Clean But Sharp Finish |
| Aroma | Herbaceous And Floral With Prominent Intensive Pungency That’s More Potent Than Its Flavor |
| Sizes | 67 Fluid Ounces |
| Affordability | Moderate |
| Other Varieties | Kirkland Signature Pure Olive Oil, Kirkland Signature Extra Virgin Olive Oil Toscano, Kirkland Signature Extra Virgin Olive Oil from Italy, Kirkland Signature Organic Cold Pressed Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Kirkland Signature Extra Virgin Olive Oil California, Kirkland Signature Spanish Extra Virgin |
Kirkland Signature’s Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil stands out for its quality, authenticity, and budget-friendly pricing. Certified organic and cold-pressed, this Italian-made oil maintains a rich flavor and nutritional profile. It’s actually one of the strongest varieties out of all mid-range grocery store olive oils, with independent testing revealing a whopping polyphenol count of over 230 mg per kilogram (+- 35.27 ounces) of oil, which is slightly higher than 50 to 200 of most affordable varieties. The purity is palpable, with a mildly herbaceous and subtle peppery aftertaste rounding off its exceptionally smooth balance. It even thickens significantly when refrigerated, another hallmark of quality.
Available online and at Costco, the Kirkland Signature range is well worth a try by anyone who’s looking for budget-friendly olive oil. For a less vibrant and ever-so-slightly milder flavor at an even cheaper price, Kirkland’s Pure Olive Oil is a great pick. It’s ideal for things like soap and lotion making, but be warned, it is blended. Kirkland Signature oils come in durable, darkened plastic containers and are set for a prolonged shelf life. The value makes them a must-see by all frugal shoppers, and the quality, flavor, and aroma have stayed consistent for years.
Bertolli Olive Oil, Extra Virgin Rich
| Origin: | Bottled In Lucca, Italy | Olives Sourced From Spain, Greece, Tunisia, Portugal, Argentina, Chile, Peru |
| Flavor | Mellow But Robust With Subtle Lingering Pepperiness |
| Aroma | Mellow, Mild, And Matched To Flavor |
| Sizes | 17 Fluid Ounces, 25.5 Fluid Ounces, 50.72 Fluid Ounces |
| Affordability | Moderate |
| Other Varieties | Bertolli Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil |
Bertolli Rich Extra Virgin Olive Oil and Bertolli Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil are two of the most reasonably priced premiere-quality imported Italian olive oils money can buy. It’s the viscosity, aroma, flavor, and aftertaste that one would expect of oils twice or more times its price, thereby putting it in the perfect affordability bracket for all-purpose versatility. Hailing from Tuscany, Italy, Bertoli has been meticulously crafting olive oil since 1865, earning global acclaim as a leading gourmet brand. Their dedication to quality shines through in every bottle, offering unparalleled flavor and value that surpasses expectations. This might just be your new favorite olive oil, no matter your cooking style.
Bertolli Olive Oil cooks better than the majority of grocery store olive oils, and even some gourmet ones, while costing about the same as an entry-level budget pick. This is where the true magic lies. There’s a crispness of flavor that bursts forth as a deep pepperiness and a bright, fresh taste, a nuance most budget brands simply can’t match. It elevates even the simplest dishes, adding a touch of gourmet flair without breaking the bank.
Whether you’re a seasoned high-end olive oil enthusiast or a budget-conscious home cook, Bertolli Olive Oil is worth a try. It’s guaranteed to surprise you with its exceptional quality and unexpected complexity.
ZOE Extra Virgin Olive
| Origin: | Spain (Processed, Bottled & Sourced) |
| Flavor | Fresh, Bold And Smooth With Rich Depth |
| Aroma | Robust, Earthy, And Herbaceous With Fresh Floral Undertones |
| Sizes | 25.5 Fluid Ounces, 33.8 Fluid Ounces, 101 Fluid Ounces |
| Affordability | Low |
| Other Varieties | ZOE Extra Virgin Olive Oil (68 Oz Plastic) |
ZOE Extra Virgin Olive Oil is another borderline premium-grade olive oil product that sells for a great price when bought in a large volume. With this being said, it’s only the larger 101.4 fluid ounces tin that is available at run-of-the-mill grocery store olive oil prices. Adversely, \its smaller tin costs more than other oils reviewed. It’s a wonderful first cold-pressed pure olive oil, which means premiere quality and the greatest depth of flavor and freshness possible. The distinctive pepperiness of good olive oil is there, while the smoothness is second to none. Customers will find that the balance of flavor is better than almost any other variety.
Those who end up falling in love with ZOE Extra Virgin Olive Oil will most likely end up needing an oil dispenser due to the tin’s weight, but other than this consideration, it’s an excellent product in every way. Expect a mild but tasty olive oil that’s ideal for everything. A little goes a long way and while not USDA certified, ZOE’s olive oils are all organic. If the pepperiness is too strong, we suggest checking out ZOE’s non-organic extra virgin olive oil or ZOE for Kids Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil for something even lighter in flavor. The company also has a premium version, namely ZOE Diva Select for those who are looking for a higher quality of oil at a reasonable price.
Iliada Extra Virgin Olive Oil
| Origin: | Greece (Processed, Bottled & Sourced) |
| Flavor | Well-Balanced Pronounced Fruitiness With Deep Peppery Aftertaste |
| Aroma | Fragrant Herbaceous Pepperiness With Robust Earthy Highlights |
| Sizes | 102 Fluid Ounces |
| Affordability | Low |
| Other Varieties | ILIADA PDO Kalamata Extra Virgin Olive Oil Greece -First Cold Pressing- Low Acidity, Iliada Greek Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil |
Olive oil aficionados who don’t want to break the bank but are still driven to find quality that’s a step above are urged to consider Iliada Extra Virgin Olive Oil. It’s Greek olive oil of the finest quality and roughly the same price as the average mid-range brand. While still considered to be a mellow mild variety, Iliada is far more robust than one would expect with pepperiness that imparts a subtle lingering bite. Its unquestionable gourmet quality becomes clear between its complexity of flavor, deep green color, and aroma that mimics the flavor profile almost exactly.
The punch of Iliada Extra Virgin Olive Oil makes it one of the best finishing oils around, while cooking is sure to impart flavor as well, thanks to its strength. As is the case with most tins, a dispenser is almost essential when opting for Iliada (don’t miss our guide to the best oil dispensers out there) due to its poor pouring spout, but this is the only caveat with a product that delivers value and flavor of oils many times its price. We can’t recommend this superior olive oil more – it’s even a firm favorite in Greece where it is imported from.
Pompeian Extra Virgin Olive Oil
| Origin: | Lucca, Italy |
| Flavor | Predominantly Neutral, Lightly Mellow With Subtle Spiciness Detactable As Faint Aftertaste |
| Aroma | Light And Fruity Aroma With Unstated But Prominent Earthiness |
| Sizes | 16 Fluid Ounces, 24 Fluid Ounces, 32 Fluid Ounces, 48 Fluid Ounces, 68 Fluid Ounces, 101 Fluid Ounces |
| Affordability | High |
| Other Varieties | Pompeian Robust Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Pompeian Light Taste Olive Oil |
Pompeian Extra Virgin Olive Oil is the brand’s forerunning leader and an excellent example of the all-around affordable excellence offered. While Pompeian’s quality remains pure (as certified by the North American Olive Oil Association) and untainted by additives and/or other oils, don’t expect any solidification in your fridge, though. The flavor profile proves to be rather flat, which will be an upside for those valuing neutrality. There’s no spiciness strongly detectable, with nothing but a rich ripeness prevalent. It’s not bad tasting but at the same time it isn’t the most flavorful or aromatic oil either. All varieties do, however, have a superb freshness and smoothness about them, and the price is near-impossible to beat.
It’s well-priced olive oil from a leader in the industry since 1906, and as such, Pompeian is reliably good. Those with dietary concerns will be happy to know that it’s gluten-free, non-allergenic, and non-GMO as well. The shaded bottle prolongs its freshness, while the intelligent pour spout gives precise control over the quantity of oil being dispensed. Overall, Pompeian Smooth Extra Virgin, Robust Extra Virgin, and Light Tasting Olive Oil are three of the best frugal choices you can make.
Notable Mentions – Good Grocery Olive Oils
- Sprouts Olive Oil – Sprouts carries Extra Virgin, Organic Extra Virgin, and 100% Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil of premier quality at affordable grocery store prices, boasting smooth, balanced flavor throughout the range.
- Publix Olive Oil – First pressed Publix Olive Oil presents outstanding value for money and mellow, mild all-purpose flavor.
- Good & Gather Olive Oil – Target’s house brand available in Extra Virgin and Extra Light Extra Virgin olive oil offers high-end quality and earthy balanced flavor at mid-range prices.
- The Fresh Market Mediterranean Extra Virgin Olive Oil – The Fresh Market’s Mediterranean Extra Virgin Olive Oil is a variety renowned for its robust flavor and aromatic pungency.
- CVS Gold Emblem Extra Virgin Olive Oil – CVS’s pure olive oil is sure to surprise new customers with its bold, rich flavor and subtle pepperiness.
- Great Value Olive Oil – Walmart’s housebrand is priced lower than almost any other olive oil reviews and the quality exceeds oh-so-many “good” brands and there’s Classic, Extra Virgin and Organic Extra Virgin available.
- Trader Joe’s Extra Virgin Olive Oil – Trader Joe’s Extra Virgin Olive Oil is a well-balanced, fruity oil sourced from select Mediterranean olives, adding a touch of elegance to your dishes with its versatile flavor profile and smooth finish.
- Simple Truth Olive Oil – Available in both Extra Virgin and Extra Light Extra Virgin, Simple Truth from Kroger, Harris Teeter, Vitacost, and City Market delivers a premium quality experience at an accessible price point.
- Carlini Pure Olive Oil – Carlini Pure Olive Oil, readily available at ALDI, boasts a clean and mild flavor suited to all-purpose versatility.
- La Española First Cold Pressed Extra Virgin Olive Oil – Indulge in the excellence of La Española First Cold Pressed Extra Virgin Olive Oil sold in stores like Walmart and online, celebrated for its authentic Spanish taste, bold aroma, and overall richness.
- Filippo Berio Olive Oil – Filippo Berio Olive Oil, a trusted classic, stands out with its well-balanced flavor and premiere quality at a reasonable price point.
Top 5 Grocery Store Olive Oil Sprays
The convenience of a good olive oil spray is unquestionable. Not only does it make dispensing oil a breeze Frugal shoppers should keep in mind that it will always be cheaper to dispense olive oil into a sprayer rather than buying an olive oil sprayer itself. Reusable dispensers save a lot of money in the long run. After all, olive oil spray typically costs twice or more per ounce as buying oil in its regular containers and quantities.
California Olive Ranch, 100% California Extra Virgin Olive Oil Spray
| Origin: | California |
| Flavor | Delicate And Well-Balanced, With A Mild Fruitiness And Subtle Hints Of Herbs |
| Aroma | Light And Fruity Aroma With Unstated But Prominent Earthiness |
| Sizes | 5 Fluid Ounces |
| Affordability | Moderate |
California Olive Ranch’s wonderfully versatile olive oil comes in a non-propellant powered sprayer that dispenses a fine mist exceptionally well. It’s a superior product in every way, from the sprayer’s superior engineering which eliminates any risk of clogging to its palatable purity. California Olive Ranch 100% Extra Virgin Olive Oil Spray has a bold and refined flavor profile, with balanced robustness reminiscent of much higher priced oils. Its carefully crafted taste adds an extra layer of richness and depth above average oils, making it a keen consideration by any discerning foodies and frugal shoppers alike.
Bertolli 100% Extra Virgin Olive Oil Spray
| Origin: | Bottled In Lucca, Italy | Olives Sourced From Spain, Greece, Tunisia, Portugal, Argentina, Chile, Peru |
| Flavor | Rich, Smooth, And Robust, Offering A Blend Of Fruity And Peppery Notes |
| Aroma | Intensely Aromatic With A Combination Of Green Freshness And A Hint Of Peppery Spice |
| Sizes | 5 Fluid Ounces |
| Affordability | Low |
Bertolli 100% Extra Virgin Olive Oil Spray arrives at a significantly higher cost than most grocery store olive oil misters, but its superior quality makes the expenditure well worth it for discerning foodies. It’s rich, robust, and highly aromatic, with mellow pepperiness and complexity that’s synonymous with good olive oil. If you’re looking for olive oil that’s close in quality to high-end select offerings most often enjoyed by connoisseurs, Bertolli is for you. There’s also Bertolli Classico 100% Olive Oil Spray available for those who prefer their oil a little lighter. After sampling either, it’ll become apparent why you pay slightly more for Bertolli – it’s worth it.
Pompeian USDA Certified Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil Non-Stick Cooking Spray
| Origin: | Lucca, Italy |
| Flavor | Robust And Mildly Spiced With Nuanced Kick |
| Aroma | Earthy And Mild With Deep Complexity Reminiscent Of Its Taste |
| Sizes | 5 Fluid Ounces |
| Affordability | Low |
Pompeian USDA Certified Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil Non-Stick Cooking Spray will set you back about double the price per ounce as its large-volume counterpart, but it truly is one of the best sprays available to shoppers. After all, Pompeian olive oil is non-GMO, vegan and it’s both USA organic and North American Olive Oil Association (NAOOA) certified. Expect one of the most robust olive oil sprays reviewed, but with this being said, it’s still best described and as mild intensity EVOO, and nothing like high polyphenol products. If you like your finishing oil to linger without breaking the bank, this is a convenience you’ve got to check out.
Mantova Organic Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil Spray
| Origin: | Italy (Processed, Bottled & Sourced) |
| Flavor | Light With Complex Subdued Depth Of Flavor |
| Aroma | Mildly Aromatic With Hints Of Earthy Freshness, Closely Matched To Its Flavor |
| Sizes | 8.5 Fluid Ounces |
| Affordability | High |
Mantova Organic Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil Spray arrives at a reasonable price, especially when one considers the USDA organic certification and the fact that it is imported. It’s real Italian olive oil with a prevailingly neutral flavor that’s tasty on just about anything. It’s actually so well-balanced that stocks are known to run out fast. Between the middle of the road affordability and mellow versatility, it’s popularity is certainly warranted.
365 by Whole Foods Market, Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil Spray
| Origin: | Undisclosed |
| Flavor | Gently Neutral With A Touch Of Earthiness And Subtle Herbaceous Undertones |
| Aroma | Mellow Aroma With Distinct Earthiness |
| Sizes | 5 Fluid Ounces |
| Affordability | Moderate |
Just like the other olive oils from 365 by Whole Foods Market, this USDA-certified organic olive oil spray is a blend of different olive oils sourced from various countries. With this being said, the flavor and aroma are superb, and the price point couldn’t be better. It works reliably and dispenses a reasonably fine mist, with functionality and flavor equal to that of much higher-priced EVOOs.
Frequently Asked Questions – Best Grocery Store Olive Oils
Have you been left wondering anything about the best grocery store olive oils? We may have the answers you’re looking for waiting here. Perhaps you’re looking to understand what makes olive oil so healthy. In that case, our look at the Top 4 Health Benefits of Eating Olive Oil EVOO Backed by Research has you covered.
The best olive oil for a budget largely depends on your flavor and intensity preference. Any pure olive oil that hasn’t been blended with other types of oil or artificial ingredients like anti-foaming agents is generally a good buy. Some cheap pure olive oils blend different varieties of olive oil from various farms and perhaps even an assortment of different countries, but the content is always olive oil alone. Pay attention to the ingredients of your prospective purchase, and if it’s nothing but olive oil across all your options, the optimal choice comes down to taste. Light olive oils are best for neutrality, extra virgin olive olive offers a mid-way point between strong and light, while robust olive oil often stated exactly as such presents the boldest flavor.
Navigating the realm of quality olive oil demands a discerning eye and a commitment to authenticity. Firstly and foremost, your olive oil must contain nothing other than olive oil itself – no other blended ingredients. Opt for olive oils housed in dark glass or tin packaging, as these materials shield the precious liquid from the damaging effects of light, preserving its flavor and nutritional integrity. Always check for a discernible harvest date, an indispensable marker of freshness and an assurance of optimal flavor. Prefer oils from a single producer or farm, as this not only enhances traceability but also signals a commitment to quality control. A lot number on the packaging serves as a unique identifier, allowing for easy tracking and accountability. Seek out olive oils with organic certification, a testament to the product’s adherence to stringent cultivation standards. The listing of a single varietal imparts a distinctive flavor profile, offering a more refined tasting experience. Moreover, transparency concerning the origin of olives and the locations of processing facilities adds another layer of trust, providing insight into the journey from grove to bottle. Once you have olive oil on hand, placing it in a refrigerator will cause it to turn slightly cloudy and solidify to a degree. When (and if) this happens, you know the purity and phenolic concentration is high, and as such, the flavor will be well-defined and clear to differentiate.
Grocery store olive oil generally falls between $0.25 to $0.60 per fluid ounce, whereas higher purity, high-concentration olive oil of high-end/gourmet varieties typically starts at $1 an ounce or more. Expect to pay around half a dollar per ounce for the best quality budget brands and around $0.35 to $0.40 for mid-range value, while bulk buys of the more frugal olive oil options cause this cost to plummet significantly towards the bottom-ground.
Does Expensive Olive Oil Actually Taste Better?
Aromatically and in terms of taste, budget, mid-tier, and high-end olive oils differ distinctly, with the latter boasting nuanced and elevated notes, particularly discernible in raw applications. Oil made from young olives like those typically used in premier varieties has a much stronger bouquet than mature olives, and bolder, intensity of flavor. With this, however, comes a greener taste that leans more on its herbaceous, peppery notes rather than subdued richness. Expensive olive oil, assuming the higher cost is reflective of a higher concentration of phenolic compounds (as it should be), has far more prominent spiciness and complexity across the entire spectrum of flavor and aroma. From its fruity and floral sweet notes to its throat tingling burn and mellow subtle off-bitter undertones, it’s all smoother, clearer and better defined regardless of whether light, extra virgin or robust first pressed olive oil is being observed. For everyday cooking, a reliable, affordable extra virgin olive oil may suffice, with the choice to indulge in a higher-end bolder finishing oil becoming a matter of personal preference, health habits, and the exact culinary applications in question.
